ELEMENTAL ARMORY BENCHMARK · LEVEL 5

Claude Sonnet 5.5 at level 5, match 39

Lost 1 to 2 with Fire/Water/Lightning/Dark against the rival's Light/Plant/Fire/Ice. The rival in its seat lost the same match. All of Claude Sonnet 5.5's matches.

RESULTLost
ROUNDS1 to 2
LEVEL5
DECISIONS4
ILLEGAL0
MODEL TIME0.5 min
COST$0.048 (API-equivalent)
TOKENS IN / OUT13,150 / 2,298
REQUESTS4

The decks

Its deck
Fire Flame Wheel ★★★, Ember Volley ★★
Water Tidal Orb ★★, Undertow ★★★
Lightning Ricochet Bolt ★★, Zap ★
Dark Siphon ★★, Gravity Well ★★
The rival's deck
Light Sunlance ★, Radiant Guard ★
Plant Seed Shot ★, Seed Sentries ★★★
Fire Cinder Comet ★★, Ember Volley ★★
Ice Ice Wall ★★★, Frost Nova ★★
The deck reply
<deck>
Fire: Flame Wheel, Ember Volley
Water: Tidal Orb, Undertow
Lightning: Ricochet Bolt, Zap
Dark: Siphon, Gravity Well
</deck>

I chose cards that hit reliably, either orbiting or pulling around the ball or travelling a long way, with some stun and healing. The four elements also cover each other's counter weaknesses.

The game's players on this match

PlayerResultRounds
Claude Sonnet 5.5Lost1 to 2
Rival in your seatLost1 to 2
Starter playerLost0 to 2
Sharp playerLost1 to 2
Tuned playerWon2 to 1

Every round

The drawings show both balls' paths from the opening launch, as the game shows the arena: the model's ball in blue starting at the bottom, the rival's in red from the top. The table has each round's launches, who won, the health left and what every card did, the game's own battle details, with the reply that chose it. The match file carries an arcade-session/1 envelope: the seed and these launches replay this exact match at Elemental Armory commit 78afdf2.

Round 1: Fire against Plant, lost
Round 2: Water against Fire, won
Round 3: Dark against Ice, lost
RoundIts launchRival's launchResultHP leftBattle details
1Fire at 20°Plant at -174.3°Fire burns PlantLost4.9 s0 / 132rival 132 / 132
Its cards: Flame Wheel: 0 hits, 0 damage; Ember Volley: 0 hits, 0 damage
Rival: Seed Shot: 2 hits, 47 damage; Seed Sentries: 2 hits, 85 damage
Reply
I'm picking Fire. It counters the rival's Plant and Ice, and the only ball that counters it is Water, which the rival doesn't have. Flame Wheel at three stars orbits the ball, so it deals damage on contact without needing a precise aim. I'm using a slight offset angle of 20 so the opening launch doesn't run straight into the rival's projectile lines.

<launch>Fire 20</launch>
2Water at 0°Fire at -44.8°Water douses FireWon4.8 s11 / 132rival 0 / 132
Its cards: Tidal Orb: 2 hits, 81 damage; Undertow: 1 hits, 51 damage
Rival: Cinder Comet: 0 hits, 64 damage; Ember Volley: 0 hits, 58 damage
Reply
I'm picking Water. It counters both Fire and Light, two of the rival's three remaining balls, and Ice isn't a clear counter to it. Tidal Orb is a long-range projectile and Undertow covers the area around my ball, so a launch straight at the rival's starting spot should give both cards the most chances to hit.

<launch>Water 0</launch>
3Dark at 20°Ice at -21.7°Lost1.9 s0 / 132rival 99 / 132
Its cards: Siphon: 1 hits, 33 damage, 4 healed; Gravity Well: 0 hits, 0 damage
Rival: Ice Wall: 3 hits, 103 damage; Frost Nova: 1 hits, 33 damage
Reply
I'm picking Dark. The rival has only Light and Ice left, and each of my two balls is countered by one of them: Light dispels Dark, and Ice grounds Lightning. So the matchup is a guess either way.

Dark looks like the safer pick for two reasons:
- **Against Light:** Light's cards are both one-star, so they deal little damage even with the counter edge.
- **Against Ice:** Siphon's healing should hold up against Ice's static, area-based cards, and Dark has no counter relationship with Ice.

I'm launching at a small angle off straight-on to avoid running directly into a pre-marked Ice Wall.

<launch>Dark 20</launch>

Angles are as each side sees the arena from its own end: 0 is straight at the other ball's start, and positive turns clockwise.