NATIONS ROYALE BENCHMARK · EASY

Claude Haiku 5.5 as VNM, Easy war 1

Won at 3:51 of game time, holding 102 provinces, 73% of the world, after 47 decisions and 3 refused orders. The game's reference player won at 4:08 on the same war. All of Claude Haiku 5.5's wars.

RESULTWon
GAME TIME3:51
HELD102 · 73%
DECISIONS47
REFUSED3 of 222
MODEL TIME7.7 min
COST$0.074 (API-equivalent)
TOKENS IN / OUT190,463 / 84,553
REQUESTS47
Share of the world at each decisionThe share of the world's provinces it held each time the war paused. Dashed lines mark the 70% seal and what the game's reference player held at the end of the same war.
0%20%40%60%80%051015Reference 75%Seal 70%Game minutes

The game's players on this war

PlayerResultHeldGame time
Claude Haiku 5.5Won73%3:51
Reference playerWon75%4:08
Reference on the model's clockWon73%5:34
Sharp personaWon78%4:26
Median personaWon74%5:38
Tourist personaTimed out7%15:00

Every decision

What it held when the war paused, the orders it gave, and what the game refused and why. The war file carries an arcade-session/1 envelope: the war key and this order stream replay this exact war at Nations Royale commit e426bd2.

DecisionClockHeldOrders
10:0011%
BUILD 41
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 93
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 104
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 41
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 93
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 104
</orders>
20:0532%
SEND 100% FROM 93 TO 67
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
BUILD 93
BUILD 104
Reply
Myanmar (67) is the cheapest target: Laos can send 21 troops against its 14. Malaysia (82) is a neutral with 15 troops, so half the capital's garrison covers it. Both neutrals are passive, and the capital keeps about 35 troops plus refill. I'll also develop Laos and Cambodia with the 70 gold this costs.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 93 TO 67
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
BUILD 93
BUILD 104
</orders>
30:1054%
BUILD 82
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 67
Reply
Philippines (43) is the only cheap target, cost 59, and I can't reach it yet with 23 troops in Malaysia. I'll build up instead. Malaysia's harbor development adds capacity and sea speed for a later strike on 43. Myanmar is my weakest frontier province with four enemy borders, so I'm moving a quarter of the capital's garrison there and keeping 45 troops at home.

<orders>
BUILD 82
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 67
</orders>
40:1554%
SEND 100% FROM 67,104,93,82 TO 42
Reply
Thailand's capital (42) holds 83 troops and costs 100 to take. Myanmar, Cambodia, Laos and Malaysia together can send about 133, so I'm committing those four at 100% and keeping the capital's 70 at home to guard against China and India.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 67,104,93,82 TO 42
</orders>
50:2054%
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 42
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 42
Reply
Thailand's capital (42) holds only 26 troops against a cost of 32, and it borders my capital. I'm sending half of Vietnam's garrison plus half of Cambodia's to take it, which gives roughly 54 troops against 26 defenders. The capital keeps about 48 troops to guard against China.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 42
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 42
</orders>
60:2564%
SEND 100% FROM 42 TO 67
BUILD 42
Reply
Thailand (42) is holding 89 troops against a cap of 46, so the excess is bleeding away. I'm moving its whole garrison into Myanmar (67), which borders Bangladesh and India. That gives 67 about 111 troops, enough to take Bangladesh (cost 85) next decision. I'm also spending the 35 gold on Thailand's muster grounds, which raises its cap and streams troops to the front.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 42 TO 67
BUILD 42
</orders>
70:3064%
SEND 100% FROM 67 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 38
RALLY 42 TO 38refused: a muster reinforces a province of yours
Reply
China is the best target. Myanmar (67) has 102 troops against a cost of 85, so it can take China on its own. I'm adding half of the capital's garrison (48) so the capture is secure, and aiming the Thailand muster at China as well.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 67 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 38
RALLY 42 TO 38
</orders>
80:3564%
SEND 50% FROM 41,93 TO 38
Reply
Taking China's capital (38) is the best opportunity. It costs 29 troops and we can send 60 against its 24. I'm sending half of the capital's garrison and half of Laos, which keeps 37 in the capital and 24 in Laos.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41,93 TO 38
</orders>
90:4075%
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 134
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 102
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 90
SEND 75% FROM 104,93 TO 41
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 134
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 102
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 90
SEND 75% FROM 104,93 TO 41
</orders>
100:45107%
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 99
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 90
BUILD 38
Reply
Taking the cheap neutral provinces first while keeping China's capital (38) garrisoned, since it folds in 11s if we hold it.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 99
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 90
BUILD 38
</orders>
110:50107%
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 50
SEND 50% FROM 93,104 TO 90
SEND 75% FROM 42 TO 99
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 50
SEND 50% FROM 93,104 TO 90
SEND 75% FROM 42 TO 99
</orders>
120:55139%
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 138
SEND 75% FROM 90 TO 70
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 110
BUILD 50
Reply
The strongest targets I can take right now are the neutrals and Taiwan, where my attacking force clearly exceeds the cost. I'm also spending the 36 gold on Mongolia's war camp, which streams troops toward the enemy on its own.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 138
SEND 75% FROM 90 TO 70
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 110
BUILD 50
</orders>
131:001612%
SEND 50% FROM 99 TO 65
SEND 100% FROM 90 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 38
Reply
Afghanistan (cost 21) is the cheapest capture available, so Tajikistan sends half its garrison there. Kyrgyzstan is interior and can reinforce Kazakhstan, which can then strike Turkmenistan (cost 21) next decision. Cambodia feeds China for the Nepal push later.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 99 TO 65
SEND 100% FROM 90 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 38
</orders>
141:051712%
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 74
SEND 75% FROM 38,50 TO 17
BUILD 48
RALLY 50 TO 17
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 74
SEND 75% FROM 38,50 TO 17
BUILD 48
RALLY 50 TO 17
</orders>
151:101813%
SEND 50% FROM 110 TO 51
SEND 75% FROM 102 TO 40
SEND 50% FROM 138 TO 40
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 48
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 110 TO 51
SEND 75% FROM 102 TO 40
SEND 50% FROM 138 TO 40
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 48
</orders>
161:152115%
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 117
BUILD 110 A
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 104,70 TO 38
RALLY 50 TO 103
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 117
BUILD 110 A
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 104,70 TO 38
RALLY 50 TO 103
</orders>
171:202115%
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 39
SEND 100% FROM 40,102 TO 39
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 122
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 65
RALLY 42 TO 43refused: a muster reinforces a province of yours
RALLY 38 TO 103refused: a muster reinforces a province of yours
Reply
Japan (39) is the cheapest big prize, so I'm hitting it from three sides. Estonia (122) gets a half-share strike from Russia's capital, which I'm keeping. I'm also moving reserves from the capital toward the Pakistan front.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 39
SEND 100% FROM 40,102 TO 39
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 122
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 65
RALLY 42 TO 43
RALLY 38 TO 103
</orders>
181:252216%
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 87
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 123
SEND 50% FROM 40 TO 39
SEND 75% FROM 50 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 65 TO 36
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 87
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 123
SEND 50% FROM 40 TO 39
SEND 75% FROM 50 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 65 TO 36
</orders>
191:302619%
SEND 75% FROM 65,99 TO 36
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 103
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 50% FROM 39,40 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 65
BUILD 40
BUILD 39
Reply
Pakistan's capital (cost 47) and Nepal (cost 53) are the nearest captures, so I'm sending enough from China, Afghanistan, Tajikistan and Vietnam's interior to take both. Oman's 75% push takes neutral Somalia (cost 14). Japan and South Korea are pooled into China's muster, and I'm building both for gold.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 65,99 TO 36
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 103
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 50% FROM 39,40 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 65
BUILD 40
BUILD 39
</orders>
201:352921%
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 103
SEND 100% FROM 110 TO 22
SEND 75% FROM 121 TO 22
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 22
BUILD 138
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 103
SEND 100% FROM 110 TO 22
SEND 75% FROM 121 TO 22
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 22
BUILD 138
</orders>
211:403122%
BUILD 123
BUILD 17
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 78
SEND 75% FROM 65 TO 22
SEND 100% FROM 122 TO 68
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 123
BUILD 17
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 78
SEND 75% FROM 65 TO 22
SEND 100% FROM 122 TO 68
</orders>
221:453324%
SEND 50% FROM 22 TO 21
SEND 75% FROM 17,117 TO 85
SEND 75% FROM 110 TO 75
BUILD 117
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 22 TO 21
SEND 75% FROM 17,117 TO 85
SEND 75% FROM 110 TO 75
BUILD 117
</orders>
231:503424%
SEND 100% FROM 75 TO 58
SEND 50% FROM 78 TO 115
RALLY 117 TO 15
BUILD 103 A
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 75 TO 58
SEND 50% FROM 78 TO 115
RALLY 117 TO 15
BUILD 103 A
</orders>
241:553626%
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 50% FROM 117 TO 85
SEND 100% FROM 75 TO 47
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 53
BUILD 22
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 50% FROM 117 TO 85
SEND 100% FROM 75 TO 47
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 53
BUILD 22
</orders>
252:004230%
SEND 100% FROM 47 TO 63
SEND 100% FROM 58 TO 71
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 75% FROM 36,38,67,103,134 TO 35
BUILD 67
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 47 TO 63
SEND 100% FROM 58 TO 71
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 75% FROM 36,38,67,103,134 TO 35
BUILD 67
</orders>
262:054532%
SEND 75% FROM 36,134 TO 35
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 75% FROM 85 TO 116
BUILD 123
Reply
Taking India's capital is the priority: it holds 10 troops against a cost of 13, and 7 more are already marching in. I'm adding 75% from Pakistan and Bhutan to make it decisive. Latvia (cost 50) gets a 50% send from Russia and a 75% send from Belarus, which together far exceed the cost. The gold goes to developing UAE for +36 gold/min.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 36,134 TO 35
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 75% FROM 85 TO 116
BUILD 123
</orders>
272:104734%
SEND 25% FROM 21 TO 53
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 111
SEND 100% FROM 71 TO 92
SEND 75% FROM 15 TO 124
SEND 75% FROM 58 TO 52
SEND 100% FROM 123,119 TO 34
BUILD 138
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 21 TO 53
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 111
SEND 100% FROM 71 TO 92
SEND 75% FROM 15 TO 124
SEND 75% FROM 58 TO 52
SEND 100% FROM 123,119 TO 34
BUILD 138
</orders>
282:155036%
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 34
SEND 25% FROM 123 TO 34
SEND 25% FROM 58 TO 52
SEND 50% FROM 35 TO 37
SEND 25% FROM 21 TO 53
BUILD 116
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 34
SEND 25% FROM 123 TO 34
SEND 25% FROM 58 TO 52
SEND 50% FROM 35 TO 37
SEND 25% FROM 21 TO 53
BUILD 116
</orders>
292:205338%
SEND 75% FROM 123 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 117 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 63,111 TO 66
SEND 50% FROM 47 TO 49
SEND 100% FROM 52 TO 72
SEND 50% FROM 67 TO 37
BUILD 34
BUILD 58
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 123 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 117 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 63,111 TO 66
SEND 50% FROM 47 TO 49
SEND 100% FROM 52 TO 72
SEND 50% FROM 67 TO 37
BUILD 34
BUILD 58
</orders>
302:255842%
SEND 25% FROM 24 TO 26
SEND 100% FROM 66 TO 69
SEND 50% FROM 34,53 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 28
BUILD 34
RALLY 22 TO 29
BUILD 24
Reply
Taking the cheap targets first: Croatia's capital (cost 10) from Hungary, and Botswana (cost 18) from Zambia. Then Egypt's capital (cost 46) gets a 50% strike from Saudi and Libya. Albania (cost 32) gets 75% from Greece. Saudi moves to Factory Lines for the gold income, Turkey's war camp aims at Egypt, and Hungary gets its war camp.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 24 TO 26
SEND 100% FROM 66 TO 69
SEND 50% FROM 34,53 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 28
BUILD 34
RALLY 22 TO 29
BUILD 24
</orders>
312:306144%
SEND 100% FROM 21,26 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 52,53 TO 54
SEND 75% FROM 49,72 TO 84
SEND 75% FROM 29 TO 24
BUILD 29
BUILD 52
RALLY 24 TO 109
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 21,26 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 52,53 TO 54
SEND 75% FROM 49,72 TO 84
SEND 75% FROM 29 TO 24
BUILD 29
BUILD 52
RALLY 24 TO 109
</orders>
322:356446%
SEND 75% FROM 63,111 TO 64
SEND 75% FROM 84 TO 55
SEND 75% FROM 21,106 TO 27
BUILD 123 B
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 63,111 TO 64
SEND 75% FROM 84 TO 55
SEND 75% FROM 21,106 TO 27
BUILD 123 B
</orders>
332:406647%
BUILD 124
SEND 75% FROM 66 TO 62
SEND 75% FROM 69 TO 83
SEND 100% FROM 84 TO 91
SEND 50% FROM 21 TO 27
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 129
Reply
is only 58, but income is +401/min, so the fortress on besieged Slovakia is affordable.

- **Build 124:** Slovakia is under siege by Ukraine, and stone walls raise its defence.
- **Namibia (62):** 75% of Zambia's 47 troops is about 35, against a cost of 15.
- **Zimbabwe (83):** 75% of Botswana's 53 troops is about 39, against a cost of 19.
- **Gabon (91):** all 20 of Congo's troops against a cost of 18. Congo is left with 1, so this is the riskiest order.
- **Serbia capital (27):** half of Greece's 129 troops, on top of the existing siege of 42, against a cost of 44.
- **Bosnia (129):** 75% of Croatia's 72 troops, about 54, against a cost of 38.

<orders>
BUILD 124
SEND 75% FROM 66 TO 62
SEND 75% FROM 69 TO 83
SEND 100% FROM 84 TO 91
SEND 50% FROM 21 TO 27
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 129
</orders>
342:457151%
SEND 100% FROM 54 TO 57
SEND 100% FROM 72,84,91 TO 79
SEND 100% FROM 24 TO 109
SEND 100% FROM 64 TO 73
BUILD 111
BUILD 124
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 54 TO 57
SEND 100% FROM 72,84,91 TO 79
SEND 100% FROM 24 TO 109
SEND 100% FROM 64 TO 73
BUILD 111
BUILD 124
</orders>
352:507353%
SEND 75% FROM 124 TO 16
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 25
SEND 75% FROM 111 TO 31
SEND 50% FROM 79 TO 57
SEND 100% FROM 138 TO 43
BUILD 55
BUILD 26
BUILD 27
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 124 TO 16
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 25
SEND 75% FROM 111 TO 31
SEND 50% FROM 79 TO 57
SEND 100% FROM 138 TO 43
BUILD 55
BUILD 26
BUILD 27
</orders>
362:557655%
SEND 75% FROM 17,15 TO 16
SEND 50% FROM 38,82 TO 43
SEND 50% FROM 64,69,62 TO 31
BUILD 116 A
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 17,15 TO 16
SEND 50% FROM 38,82 TO 43
SEND 50% FROM 64,69,62 TO 31
BUILD 116 A
</orders>
373:007957%
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 100% FROM 91 TO 30
SEND 50% FROM 22,24,27 TO 23
SEND 75% FROM 31 TO 57
BUILD 41 A
BUILD 31
RALLY 26 TO 88
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 100% FROM 91 TO 30
SEND 50% FROM 22,24,27 TO 23
SEND 75% FROM 31 TO 57
BUILD 41 A
BUILD 31
RALLY 26 TO 88
</orders>
383:058058%
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 23
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 56
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 88
BUILD 57 A
BUILD 16 A
Reply
Romania's capital (23) is the best target: it costs 10 troops to take and borders Ukraine, Serbia and Hungary. Taking it and Moldova (133) would remove most of Romania, and I need about 18 more provinces to reach 70%. Mali (56) and Burkina Faso (88) are also cheap to take, so I'm sending enough to each. Gold covers two supply-depot upgrades on Niger and Ukraine.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 23
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 56
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 88
BUILD 57 A
BUILD 16 A
</orders>
393:108360%
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 113
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 86
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 19
SEND 100% FROM 15,25,109 TO 10
SEND 100% FROM 68 TO 18
BUILD 91
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 113
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 86
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 19
SEND 100% FROM 15,25,109 TO 10
SEND 100% FROM 68 TO 18
BUILD 91
</orders>
403:158662%
SEND 25% FROM 88 TO 86
SEND 50% FROM 113 TO 127
SEND 50% FROM 25 TO 10
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 89
BUILD 26
BUILD 24
Reply
Holding 86 of the 98 provinces needed for the 70% win, so I'm pressing cheap captures: Ivory Coast, Germany's capital and Guinea, plus relieving Burkina Faso by hitting Togo. I'm also developing the two war camps for more garrison.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 88 TO 86
SEND 50% FROM 113 TO 127
SEND 50% FROM 25 TO 10
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 89
BUILD 26
BUILD 24
</orders>
413:209065%
SEND 75% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 75% FROM 86 TO 118
SEND 75% FROM 10 TO 135
SEND 75% FROM 17,68 TO 19
BUILD 10
BUILD 56
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 75% FROM 86 TO 118
SEND 75% FROM 10 TO 135
SEND 75% FROM 17,68 TO 19
BUILD 10
BUILD 56
</orders>
423:259266%
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 14
SEND 50% FROM 88 TO 46
SEND 75% FROM 89 TO 97
SEND 50% FROM 86 TO 118
BUILD 109
BUILD 15
BUILD 68
BUILD 64
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 14
SEND 50% FROM 88 TO 46
SEND 75% FROM 89 TO 97
SEND 50% FROM 86 TO 118
BUILD 109
BUILD 15
BUILD 68
BUILD 64
</orders>
433:309568%
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 125
SEND 75% FROM 135 TO 14
SEND 75% FROM 89 TO 126
BUILD 109
BUILD 19
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 125
SEND 75% FROM 135 TO 14
SEND 75% FROM 89 TO 126
BUILD 109
BUILD 19
</orders>
443:359669%
SEND 25% FROM 118,89 TO 126
SEND 25% FROM 10 TO 125
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 128
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 59
SEND 100% FROM 57 TO 33
BUILD 88
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 118,89 TO 126
SEND 25% FROM 10 TO 125
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 128
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 59
SEND 100% FROM 57 TO 33
BUILD 88
</orders>
453:409971%
SEND 75% FROM 118 TO 33
SEND 50% FROM 135 TO 9
BUILD 135
BUILD 118
BUILD 10 A
Reply
The hold is at 71.2%, so the priority is keeping that margin while using overflowing provinces to take weakly held targets. Liberia (245 troops, cap 46) and Belgium (277, cap 46) are far over cap. Algeria's 70 defenders are beatable with Liberia's surplus, and France's cost of 60 is covered by Belgium's send.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 118 TO 33
SEND 50% FROM 135 TO 9
BUILD 135
BUILD 118
BUILD 10 A
</orders>
463:4510173%
SEND 25% FROM 57 TO 33
BUILD 57
BUILD 135
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 57 TO 33
BUILD 57
BUILD 135
</orders>
473:5010273%
BUILD 33
BUILD 59
Reply
The hold timer is at 14s of 15s and we're at 73.4% of the map, about 5 provinces above the 70% threshold. The priority is to avoid losing ground for the next 5 seconds, so I'm not attacking. I'm only spending 70 of our 201 gold on two cheap frontier upgrades in the newly taken provinces, which raises their garrison caps without changing the front.

<orders>
BUILD 33
BUILD 59
</orders>