NATIONS ROYALE BENCHMARK · MEDIUM

Claude Haiku 5.5 as VNM, Medium war 1

Won at 7:00 of game time, holding 100 provinces, 72% of the world, after 84 decisions and 5 refused orders. The game's reference player lost at 5:53 on the same war. All of Claude Haiku 5.5's wars.

RESULTWon
GAME TIME7:00
HELD100 · 72%
DECISIONS84
REFUSED5 of 364
MODEL TIME16.4 min
COST$0.153 (API-equivalent)
TOKENS IN / OUT360,393 / 186,605
REQUESTS84
Share of the world at each decisionThe share of the world's provinces it held each time the war paused. The dashed line marks the 70% seal.
0%20%40%60%051015Seal 70%Game minutes

The game's players on this war

PlayerResultHeldGame time
Claude Haiku 5.5Won72%7:00
Reference playerLost0%5:53
Reference on the model's clockLost0%12:34
Sharp personaWon73%9:53
Median personaTimed out4%15:00
Tourist personaLost0%6:29

Every decision

What it held when the war paused, the orders it gave, and what the game refused and why. The war file carries an arcade-session/1 envelope: the war key and this order stream replay this exact war at Nations Royale commit e426bd2.

DecisionClockHeldOrders
10:0011%
BUILD 41
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 93
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 104
Reply
Taking the two cheap neutral provinces next to my capital, and developing the capital first so its cap and defence rise before the troops leave.

<orders>
BUILD 41
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 93
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 104
</orders>
20:0532%
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 67
BUILD 93
BUILD 104
Reply
Taking the two neutral provinces next to me is the cheapest gain. Malaysia (cost 15) gets half of my capital's garrison, which leaves a comfortable margin. Myanmar (cost 14) gets 75% of Laos's garrison, a tighter margin but enough to win. I'm also developing both held provinces: Laos to a fortress for defence, and Cambodia to a muster to feed the front. That spends 70 of my 113 gold.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 67
BUILD 93
BUILD 104
</orders>
30:1043%
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
BUILD 67
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 67
Reply
Holding the capital at 57 troops while hitting Malaysia/Philippines at 82 with 50% from 41 gives about 40 against their 24 defenders. Myanmar is my most exposed province, so I'm fortifying it and moving some Cambodian troops to reinforce it.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
BUILD 67
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 67
</orders>
40:1543%
SEND 75% FROM 41 TO 82
Reply
Malaysia (82) is the cheapest target at cost 37. Capital 41 can send 75% of its 53 troops, about 39, which should just exceed that. The capital keeps the rest and refills over time. I'm not attacking the larger neighbours yet, since none of them is affordable from my current garrisons.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 41 TO 82
</orders>
50:2043%waited
Reply
Holding for now. Taking Malaysia (cost 24) with 75% of the capital would leave only about 12 troops in Vietnam, which is too thin with China (115) on the border. I'll let the capital's garrison refill before attacking.

<orders></orders>
60:2543%
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 82
SEND 100% FROM 67 TO 38
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 38
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 82
SEND 100% FROM 67 TO 38
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 38
</orders>
70:3043%
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
RALLY 104 TO 42refused: a muster reinforces a province of yours
Reply
Malaysia (82) is the only target I can take now. Its cost is 32 and I can send 37 from the capital (50% of 75), which keeps 38 at home. Cambodia is full at 56/56 and borders only Thailand, which costs 100 to take, so I'm aiming its muster there to build up for later.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
RALLY 104 TO 42
</orders>
80:3543%
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 82
SEND 75% FROM 93,67 TO 38
SEND 100% FROM 104 TO 41
Reply
The capital is the priority. Taking Malaysia (cost 5) is cheap and nearly free, so I'll use a quarter of the capital's garrison for it. I'll attack China with 75% of Laos and Myanmar, which should just clear its cost of 46. The full muster at Cambodia can reinforce the capital, which is exposed to Thailand's 83 troops across the sea.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 82
SEND 75% FROM 93,67 TO 38
SEND 100% FROM 104 TO 41
</orders>
90:4054%
SEND 25% FROM 41,93 TO 38
BUILD 82
Reply
Capturing China (48 troops) is the best immediate move. Our 22 troops already sieging it plus a 25% send from the capital and 25% from Laos gives about 58 against 48, enough to win with a margin. Malaysia's harbor (35g) is affordable and adds sea speed for later strikes on the Philippines and Indonesia.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 41,93 TO 38
BUILD 82
</orders>
100:4554%
SEND 75% FROM 41 TO 38
Reply
Attacking China's capital now. Our 75% send (about 88 troops) exceeds its 78-troop cost, and our capital is near its cap, so waiting would waste regeneration. The main risk is Thailand's 83 troops next to our depleted capital, which I'll watch next decision.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 41 TO 38
</orders>
110:5054%
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
Reply
Philippines (43) is the cheapest target at cost 36. Sending 75% of Malaysia (82) gives about 42 troops against it, which should win. Malaysia keeps about 14 and refills toward its cap of 56. The other borders cost 81 or more, so I'm holding those troops until the Philippines attack resolves.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
</orders>
120:5554%
SEND 50% FROM 41,93 TO 38
SEND 100% FROM 82 TO 43
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41,93 TO 38
SEND 100% FROM 82 TO 43
</orders>
131:0043%
SEND 75% FROM 67,93 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
RALLY 104 TO 38refused: a muster reinforces a province of yours
Reply
Key facts: China's capital (38) has 43 troops against my cost of 52, and I can reach it from Myanmar (67) and Laos (93). Malaysia (82) costs 18 and is 17-held, so half my capital's garrison can take it by sea while keeping 35 troops at home. Thailand (42, 63 troops) is too strong to attack yet, so I'll aim the full muster at China as well.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 67,93 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
RALLY 104 TO 38
</orders>
141:0564%
BUILD 38
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 134
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 99
BUILD 82
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 38
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 134
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 99
BUILD 82
</orders>
151:1075%
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 99
RALLY 104 TO 42refused: a muster reinforces a province of yours
Reply
The main risks are the Japanese stacks around China's capital (38) and Thailand's 64 troops next to my capital. Cambodia is full at 56/56 and wasting output, so I'm aiming its muster at Thailand. I'm also taking Tajikistan (cost 1) with a small share from 38.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 99
RALLY 104 TO 42
</orders>
161:1586%
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 38
SEND 75% FROM 104 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 134 TO 38
Reply
Province 38 is the priority. Holding it for 7 seconds folds China, but Nepal's 31 troops arrive in 1 second against 27 defenders. I'm sending reinforcements from the capital, the muster at Cambodia, and Bhutan. Routing depends on the own-land path, which I can't confirm from the report.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 38
SEND 75% FROM 104 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 134 TO 38
</orders>
171:2086%
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 90
SEND 100% FROM 99 TO 90
Reply
The order that matters most is keeping CHINA's capital (38) for the 2-second countdown, so I'm not sending its garrison out. I'm sending only 25% of it (about 21 troops) against neutral KYRGYZSTAN (90), which costs 15, so the attack wins and 38 keeps about 65 defenders against Japan's neighbouring forces. Everything else is too thin to attack a neighbour this turn.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 90
SEND 100% FROM 99 TO 90
</orders>
181:25107%
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 104
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 50
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 48
SEND 75% FROM 90 TO 70
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 104
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 50
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 48
SEND 75% FROM 90 TO 70
</orders>
191:30129%
SEND 100% FROM 38,90 TO 48
SEND 100% FROM 99,70 TO 65
BUILD 50
RALLY 50 TO 17
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 38,90 TO 48
SEND 100% FROM 99,70 TO 65
BUILD 50
RALLY 50 TO 17
</orders>
201:351410%
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 100% FROM 50 TO 17
BUILD 48
SEND 75% FROM 67,93,104 TO 42
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 42
Reply
Taking Russia (cost 19) is the cheapest gain, so I'm committing Kazakhstan and Mongolia to it. Thailand's capital costs 115, and sending 75% from Myanmar, Laos and Cambodia plus 25% from the capital gives about 142 troops against it. Gold goes to Kazakhstan's supply depots, which raise its cap and let troops stack.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 100% FROM 50 TO 17
BUILD 48
SEND 75% FROM 67,93,104 TO 42
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 42
</orders>
211:401511%
SEND 50% FROM 82 TO 38
SEND 75% FROM 70 TO 74
SEND 50% FROM 65 TO 74
Reply
Province 17 (Russia) will probably fall to the Turkish and Japanese columns arriving now, and I can't reinforce it in time. The best moves are to take the neutral Turkmenistan (cost 22) and to stop Japan from taking China (38).

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 82 TO 38
SEND 75% FROM 70 TO 74
SEND 50% FROM 65 TO 74
</orders>
221:451410%
SEND 50% FROM 90,134,103 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 67,93,104,82 TO 42
SEND 75% FROM 48,50 TO 17
BUILD 90
Reply
The main opportunities are China (38), Thailand's capital (42), and Russia (17), where a column is already arriving. I'm committing about 50% from the provinces adjacent to each target, keeping Vietnam's capital and Tajikistan out of the attack. Gold goes to developing Kyrgyzstan's defences.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 90,134,103 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 67,93,104,82 TO 42
SEND 75% FROM 48,50 TO 17
BUILD 90
</orders>
231:501612%
SEND 50% FROM 65,70 TO 74
BUILD 65
BUILD 99
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 65
Reply
Turkmenistan (74) is held by Japan with 12 troops against a cost of 13, so a 50% push from Afghanistan and Uzbekistan should take it. Russia (17) is under heavy incoming attack and is likely lost, so I'm not reinforcing it. The capital is overcapped at 126/123, so I'm moving half of it toward the Afghanistan front to stage for Iran. I'm also spending 70 of my 81 gold on stone walls at the two frontier provinces.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 65,70 TO 74
BUILD 65
BUILD 99
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 65
</orders>
241:551612%
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 50 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 65 TO 51
SEND 100% FROM 74 TO 51
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 74
SEND 50% FROM 90 TO 65
Reply
Romania holds Russia's capital (17) with 15 troops, and our column of 8 is still four seconds out. I'm committing about 34 more troops from Kazakhstan and Mongolia to take it. Iran (51) is neutral with 34 troops, so I'm attacking it from Afghanistan and Turkmenistan with about 42 troops. Interior provinces 93 and 90 reinforce the frontier behind them. I'm skipping BUILD because we have only 25 gold.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 50 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 65 TO 51
SEND 100% FROM 74 TO 51
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 74
SEND 50% FROM 90 TO 65
</orders>
252:001712%
SEND 50% FROM 67,103 TO 38
BUILD 42
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 67,103 TO 38
BUILD 42
</orders>
262:051712%
SEND 75% FROM 48,50 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 65 TO 36
SEND 50% FROM 99 TO 36
BUILD 74
Reply
Russia's capital (17) is the cheapest high-value target: it costs 14 and is held by Japan. Pakistan's capital (36) costs 77, so I'll combine two sources to clear it. Turkmenistan gets supply depots for 35 gold.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 48,50 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 65 TO 36
SEND 50% FROM 99 TO 36
BUILD 74
</orders>
272:101612%
SEND 75% FROM 74 TO 65
SEND 75% FROM 51,99 TO 36
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 51
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 74 TO 65
SEND 75% FROM 51,99 TO 36
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 51
</orders>
282:151813%
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 17
SEND 100% FROM 36 TO 87
BUILD 36
RALLY 50 TO 17
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 17
SEND 100% FROM 36 TO 87
BUILD 36
RALLY 50 TO 17
</orders>
292:201914%
BUILD 51
SEND 75% FROM 51 TO 77
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
RALLY 36 TO 17
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 51
SEND 75% FROM 51 TO 77
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
RALLY 36 TO 17
</orders>
302:251813%
SEND 50% FROM 90,93 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 36
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
BUILD 134
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 90,93 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 36
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
BUILD 134
</orders>
312:302014%
SEND 100% FROM 50 TO 38
BUILD 74
RALLY 36 TO 38
RALLY 50 TO 38
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 50 TO 38
BUILD 74
RALLY 36 TO 38
RALLY 50 TO 38
</orders>
322:352115%
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 43
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 75% FROM 74 TO 110
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 43
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 75% FROM 74 TO 110
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
</orders>
332:402115%
BUILD 77
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 100% FROM 36,134,103 TO 35
SEND 50% FROM 67 TO 35
SEND 75% FROM 42 TO 67
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 77
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 100% FROM 36,134,103 TO 35
SEND 50% FROM 67 TO 35
SEND 75% FROM 42 TO 67
</orders>
342:452317%
SEND 75% FROM 50 TO 36
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 74 TO 42
BUILD 17
Reply
Thailand (42) and Russia (17) are the most urgent. Indonesia's 59 troops hit Thailand in 1s, and Russia faces Turkey's siege plus Sweden's 27 arriving in 3s. Pakistan (36) also has an incoming column from Ukraine. The capital is full at 126 with no enemy beside it, so it can spare troops. Mongolia is over its cap, so its surplus should move first.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 50 TO 36
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 74 TO 42
BUILD 17
</orders>
352:502115%
SEND 75% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 100% FROM 82 TO 43
SEND 100% FROM 87 TO 123
SEND 75% FROM 70,74 TO 48
RALLY 36 TO 35
RALLY 50 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 42
BUILD 65
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 100% FROM 82 TO 43
SEND 100% FROM 87 TO 123
SEND 75% FROM 70,74 TO 48
RALLY 36 TO 35
RALLY 50 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 42
BUILD 65
</orders>
362:552216%
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 121
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 110
SEND 50% FROM 36,103 TO 38
BUILD 104
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 121
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 110
SEND 50% FROM 36,103 TO 38
BUILD 104
</orders>
373:002216%
SEND 75% FROM 67 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 50 TO 38
SEND 100% FROM 82 TO 43
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 110
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 67 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 50 TO 38
SEND 100% FROM 82 TO 43
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 110
</orders>
383:052417%
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 43
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
SEND 50% FROM 35,67 TO 37
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
BUILD 110
BUILD 123
Reply
Capital 41 can spare half its garrison without risk. The main moves are a cheap sea grab on the Philippines, reinforcing the Bangladesh capital assault, and reinforcing besieged Somalia. Gold covers two workshop upgrades.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 43
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
SEND 50% FROM 35,67 TO 37
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
BUILD 110
BUILD 123
</orders>
393:102317%
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 35,67 TO 37
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 43
RALLY 50 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 74 TO 110
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 35,67 TO 37
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 43
RALLY 50 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 74 TO 110
</orders>
403:152619%
BUILD 110
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 75% FROM 110 TO 121
SEND 50% FROM 50 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 75
SEND 50% FROM 74 TO 110
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 110
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 75% FROM 110 TO 121
SEND 50% FROM 50 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 75
SEND 50% FROM 74 TO 110
</orders>
413:202820%
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 75% FROM 75 TO 47
BUILD 123 A
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 75% FROM 75 TO 47
BUILD 123 A
</orders>
423:252820%
SEND 25% FROM 75 TO 47
SEND 100% FROM 110 TO 22
SEND 75% FROM 123 TO 34
BUILD 17
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 75 TO 47
SEND 100% FROM 110 TO 22
SEND 75% FROM 123 TO 34
BUILD 17
</orders>
433:302921%
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 22
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 74 TO 77
BUILD 48
RALLY 50 TO 17
Reply
Vietnam's main opening is Turkey's capital (22), which is cheap to take now. Russia's capital (17) is also worth a larger push, since two columns are already on it. Kazakhstan's granaries are affordable and boost its capacity heavily. Turkmenistan's troops go to Iraq to reinforce the front, and the war camp in Mongolia is aimed at Russia.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 51 TO 22
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 74 TO 77
BUILD 48
RALLY 50 TO 17
</orders>
443:353022%
SEND 50% FROM 121 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 75% FROM 47 TO 63
BUILD 77
Reply
Taking Russia's capital (cost 5) and Jordan (cost 40) are the cheapest gains, and Tanzania (cost 23) is reachable from Kenya. Factory Lines on Iraq adds the most gold for the 80g I can spend.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 121 TO 17
SEND 50% FROM 77 TO 119
SEND 75% FROM 47 TO 63
BUILD 77
</orders>
453:403324%
SEND 75% FROM 77 TO 96
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
RALLY 50 TO 122
BUILD 35
BUILD 43
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 77 TO 96
SEND 75% FROM 48 TO 17
RALLY 50 TO 122
BUILD 35
BUILD 43
</orders>
463:453324%
SEND 75% FROM 47,75 TO 58
BUILD 35
Reply
I'm taking Ethiopia (58) with a combined push from Kenya (47) and Somalia (75). Their 75% shares add up to about 80 troops against its 56 cost. I'm also developing India (35) to Conscription with the 110 gold.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 47,75 TO 58
BUILD 35
</orders>
473:503827%
SEND 100% FROM 119 TO 29
BUILD 119
BUILD 47
RALLY 22 TO 106
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 119 TO 29
BUILD 119
BUILD 47
RALLY 22 TO 106
</orders>
483:553827%
BUILD 34
SEND 50% FROM 110,48 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 36 TO 38
Reply
I'm holding the Egypt capital siege as it stands, since the 85 troops already committed exceed its 65 cost. The main concerns are Russia, which is under three sieges with Mexican reinforcements arriving, and China, which Japan is besieging. I'm sending interior troops to both. The Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan routing to Russia is an assumption about adjacency that the report doesn't confirm. Gold goes to Saudi's workshops for income.

<orders>
BUILD 34
SEND 50% FROM 110,48 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 36 TO 38
</orders>
494:003727%
BUILD 34
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 83
SEND 50% FROM 110 TO 17
RALLY 47 TO 58
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 34
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 83
SEND 50% FROM 110 TO 17
RALLY 47 TO 58
</orders>
504:054029%
SEND 75% FROM 47 TO 92
SEND 75% FROM 83 TO 69
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 73
SEND 75% FROM 63,111 TO 66
SEND 75% FROM 78,58 TO 115
BUILD 17
Reply
The Egypt capital at 29 stays put. The orders below take the cheapest reachable provinces with enough margin, and I'm developing Russia, which is under attack from Sweden and Mexico.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 47 TO 92
SEND 75% FROM 83 TO 69
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 73
SEND 75% FROM 63,111 TO 66
SEND 75% FROM 78,58 TO 115
BUILD 17
</orders>
514:104432%
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 40
SEND 100% FROM 64 TO 55
BUILD 17
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 42
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 40
SEND 100% FROM 64 TO 55
BUILD 17
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 42
</orders>
524:154532%
SEND 50% FROM 66 TO 55
SEND 50% FROM 74,48 TO 17
BUILD 42
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 66 TO 55
SEND 50% FROM 74,48 TO 17
BUILD 42
</orders>
534:204633%
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 40
SEND 100% FROM 22 TO 106
BUILD 83
BUILD 42 A
Reply
Russia's garrison is covered by the 227 troops already moving in, so I'm sending a small 25% strike from it to South Korea's capital (cost 10). Turkey's full garrison goes at Bulgaria to beat its cost of 51 once the 7 incoming troops arrive. Zimbabwe's workshops add gold income, and Thailand's conscription speeds up front-line reinforcement. The fork letter for Thailand is a guess, since the report doesn't say which option is A.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 40
SEND 100% FROM 22 TO 106
BUILD 83
BUILD 42 A
</orders>
544:254633%
SEND 25% FROM 83 TO 31
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 31
SEND 75% FROM 29 TO 53
SEND 75% FROM 55 TO 62
SEND 75% FROM 58,92 TO 71
BUILD 58
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 83 TO 31
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 31
SEND 75% FROM 29 TO 53
SEND 75% FROM 55 TO 62
SEND 75% FROM 58,92 TO 71
BUILD 58
</orders>
554:304734%
SEND 75% FROM 47 TO 71
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 31
SEND 50% FROM 66,55 TO 62
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
BUILD 83 A
SEND 75% FROM 74,48 TO 17
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 47 TO 71
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 31
SEND 50% FROM 66,55 TO 62
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 43
BUILD 83 A
SEND 75% FROM 74,48 TO 17
</orders>
564:355036%
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 117
SEND 75% FROM 31 TO 84
SEND 100% FROM 62 TO 54
BUILD 31
BUILD 62
Reply
Plan: take cheap Swedish provinces off Russia (Poland's capital and Lithuania), use the idle interior stacks against Nigeria's Congo and Chad, and spend gold on the two cheap T0 upgrades.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 117
SEND 75% FROM 31 TO 84
SEND 100% FROM 62 TO 54
BUILD 31
BUILD 62
</orders>
574:405137%
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 85
SEND 50% FROM 52 TO 53
SEND 100% FROM 83,110,123 TO 63
SEND 50% FROM 42 TO 42refused: a province cannot send to itself
BUILD 43
BUILD 96
RALLY 22 TO 23
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 85
SEND 50% FROM 52 TO 53
SEND 100% FROM 83,110,123 TO 63
SEND 50% FROM 42 TO 42
BUILD 43
BUILD 96
RALLY 22 TO 23
</orders>
584:455540%
SEND 50% FROM 117 TO 116
SEND 50% FROM 84 TO 91
SEND 50% FROM 63 TO 49
SEND 75% FROM 52 TO 72
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 72
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 24
BUILD 66
BUILD 106
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 117 TO 116
SEND 50% FROM 84 TO 91
SEND 50% FROM 63 TO 49
SEND 75% FROM 52 TO 72
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 72
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 24
BUILD 66
BUILD 106
</orders>
594:505842%
SEND 25% FROM 63 TO 49
SEND 50% FROM 84 TO 91
SEND 50% FROM 52 TO 72
BUILD 41 A
BUILD 63
Reply
Gold and the marching columns cover the cheap, nearby targets. I'm taking the three easy captures, buying the capital fortress upgrade, and adding a muster at Tanzania.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 63 TO 49
SEND 50% FROM 84 TO 91
SEND 50% FROM 52 TO 72
BUILD 41 A
BUILD 63
</orders>
604:555942%
SEND 50% FROM 49 TO 79
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 54
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
BUILD 17 B
Reply
Nigeria's capital is the nearest big prize, so I'm staging troops in Chad for it. Cameroon falls to DR Congo's push, Russia gets reinforced against Mexico's siege, and Russia's Assembly Point development uses most of the gold.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 49 TO 79
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 54
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 17
BUILD 17 B
</orders>
615:005942%
SEND 50% FROM 54 TO 30
SEND 25% FROM 72 TO 79
SEND 50% FROM 53 TO 57
BUILD 116
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 54 TO 30
SEND 25% FROM 72 TO 79
SEND 50% FROM 53 TO 57
BUILD 116
</orders>
625:055942%
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 122
SEND 50% FROM 116 TO 117
SEND 75% FROM 54 TO 30
SEND 50% FROM 53 TO 57
SEND 50% FROM 74,48 TO 17
BUILD 106 A
Reply
Russia (17) has the most surplus, with 250 troops, a cap of 156, and 294 more on the way, so it can spare a large push at Estonia (cost 94). Chad (54) is over cap at 70/46, so it can send a strong force at Nigeria's capital (cost 29). Libya (53) can take Niger (cost 7) with half its garrison. Latvia (116) reinforces the besieged Lithuania (117). Interior Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan feed Russia, which faces the most enemies. Bulgaria (106) gets its garrison keep upgrade, which is the best use of the 106 gold.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 122
SEND 50% FROM 116 TO 117
SEND 75% FROM 54 TO 30
SEND 50% FROM 53 TO 57
SEND 50% FROM 74,48 TO 17
BUILD 106 A
</orders>
635:106245%
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 113
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 23
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 19
BUILD 66
BUILD 57
Reply
tays put, so its 17-second countdown keeps running. I'm pressing three attacks and spending gold on the economy.

- **Benin (113):** 50% of Niger (57) is about 30 troops against a cost of 26. Niger keeps enough to hold against Mali and Burkina Faso.
- **Romania capital (23):** 75% of Bulgaria (106) is about 73 troops against a cost of 67. Taking it eliminates Romania, which has only this province.
- **Norway capital (19):** 75% of Russia (17) is about 114 troops against a cost of 98. Russia gets reinforced by the large column arriving now and can absorb the incoming Mexican attack.
- **Economy:** Zambia's factory lines (+36 gold/min) and Niger's supply depots use 115 of my 121 gold.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 113
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 23
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 19
BUILD 66
BUILD 57
</orders>
645:156245%
SEND 50% FROM 48,35,50,103 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 39
SEND 50% FROM 22,106 TO 23
BUILD 29
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 48,35,50,103 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 39
SEND 50% FROM 22,106 TO 23
BUILD 29
</orders>
655:206245%
SEND 25% FROM 67,90,93,99,134 TO 38
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 19
SEND 50% FROM 66 TO 57
BUILD 82
BUILD 122
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 67,90,93,99,134 TO 38
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 19
SEND 50% FROM 66 TO 57
BUILD 82
BUILD 122
</orders>
665:256345%
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 39
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 40
SEND 50% FROM 41,42 TO 104
BUILD 82
BUILD 38
Reply
The capital of Nigeria (30) is ours and folds in 2s if we hold it, so I'm keeping it safe. Russia (17) has 696 troops, so I'm sending a quarter of them at Japan's capital (39, cost 13). I'm also attacking S. Korea's capital (40) from China, and Cambodia (104) from our capital and Thailand. Gold goes to developing Malaysia and China.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 39
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 40
SEND 50% FROM 41,42 TO 104
BUILD 82
BUILD 38
</orders>
675:306849%
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 18
SEND 75% FROM 23 TO 24
SEND 25% FROM 35 TO 37
BUILD 41
Reply
The biggest opening is Russia's 489 troops. A 25% send to Finland (cost 98) and a 50% send to Poland (cost 97) both fit, since the second share is taken from what remains. Norway and Romania can each take a capital with a 75% send, and Bangladesh (cost 7) falls to a 25% send from Mali's neighbour Latvia. Gold goes to the capital citadel, which protects the most important province.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 18
SEND 75% FROM 23 TO 24
SEND 25% FROM 35 TO 37
BUILD 41
</orders>
685:357252%
SEND 50% FROM 39 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 39 TO 138
SEND 75% FROM 127 TO 46
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 15
BUILD 39
Reply
Japan's capital is ours and holds 408 troops, so I'm using it to strike North Korea and Taiwan. Togo's 145 troops can take Ghana's capital. Russia covers Finland and Poland. I'm also developing Japan to a naval base for faster sea moves.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 39 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 39 TO 138
SEND 75% FROM 127 TO 46
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 15
BUILD 39
</orders>
695:407554%
SEND 50% FROM 102 TO 40
SEND 50% FROM 43 TO 138
SEND 25% FROM 117 TO 85
SEND 25% FROM 122 TO 68
SEND 75% FROM 46 TO 86
SEND 75% FROM 22,29,106 TO 21
BUILD 17
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 102 TO 40
SEND 50% FROM 43 TO 138
SEND 25% FROM 117 TO 85
SEND 25% FROM 122 TO 68
SEND 75% FROM 46 TO 86
SEND 75% FROM 22,29,106 TO 21
BUILD 17
</orders>
705:457655%
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 25
SEND 50% FROM 68 TO 18
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 56
SEND 75% FROM 54,52 TO 53
BUILD 122 B
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 25
SEND 50% FROM 68 TO 18
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 56
SEND 75% FROM 54,52 TO 53
BUILD 122 B
</orders>
715:508158%
SEND 100% FROM 86 TO 118
SEND 100% FROM 57 TO 53
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 16
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 17
BUILD 38
BUILD 85
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 86 TO 118
SEND 100% FROM 57 TO 53
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 16
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 17
BUILD 38
BUILD 85
</orders>
725:558259%
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 16
SEND 100% FROM 25 TO 109
SEND 100% FROM 35,82 TO 130
BUILD 40 B
BUILD 25
BUILD 38
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 16
SEND 100% FROM 25 TO 109
SEND 100% FROM 35,82 TO 130
BUILD 40 B
BUILD 25
BUILD 38
</orders>
736:008360%
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 16
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 25
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 17
BUILD 127
BUILD 85
Reply
Ukraine's capital (16) is the biggest prize in reach. I'm sending half of Russia's stack there, where a 400-troop siege is already arriving. Czechia (25) costs only 28, so half of Poland's garrison covers it. China's overflow goes to the front at Russia, and I'm spending 160 gold on two cheap develops.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 16
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 25
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 17
BUILD 127
BUILD 85
</orders>
746:058360%
SEND 75% FROM 15,18 TO 10
SEND 100% FROM 56 TO 97
BUILD 66 B
Reply
Ukraine's capital (16) already has 761 troops inbound, so I'm leaving it alone. The main additional gains are Germany's capital (10) and Senegal (97). Turkmenistan's Grand Depot would help stacking, but Zambia's Trade Exchange adds gold for the next push.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 15,18 TO 10
SEND 100% FROM 56 TO 97
BUILD 66 B
</orders>
756:108561%
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 9
SEND 50% FROM 24 TO 109
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 124
SEND 100% FROM 86,118 TO 89
SEND 100% FROM 35,82 TO 130
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 0
BUILD 40
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 9
SEND 50% FROM 24 TO 109
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 124
SEND 100% FROM 86,118 TO 89
SEND 100% FROM 35,82 TO 130
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 0
BUILD 40
</orders>
766:158763%
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 100% FROM 86,118 TO 89
SEND 100% FROM 18,19 TO 125
RALLY 17 TO 0refused: RUSSIA#17 has no war camp or muster to rally
BUILD 16 A
Reply
Plan: take the cheap neighbours (Moldova, Senegal, Guinea, Denmark) while the large Russian and Ukrainian stacks hold the front. Ukraine's capital stays ours to finish that nation.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 100% FROM 86,118 TO 89
SEND 100% FROM 18,19 TO 125
RALLY 17 TO 0
BUILD 16 A
</orders>
776:208863%
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 0
SEND 50% FROM 16 TO 27
SEND 50% FROM 133 TO 26
SEND 50% FROM 89 TO 97
BUILD 133 A
BUILD 124
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 0
SEND 50% FROM 16 TO 27
SEND 50% FROM 133 TO 26
SEND 50% FROM 89 TO 97
BUILD 133 A
BUILD 124
</orders>
786:258964%
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 109
SEND 100% FROM 21 TO 27
SEND 100% FROM 24 TO 26
SEND 100% FROM 35 TO 130
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 0
BUILD 16
Reply
The biggest gains are the cheap capitals and the weakly held border provinces, so I'm attacking those with enough force to clear their costs. Russia's surplus goes to the USA capital, which is already under siege.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 109
SEND 100% FROM 21 TO 27
SEND 100% FROM 24 TO 26
SEND 100% FROM 35 TO 130
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 0
BUILD 16
</orders>
796:309367%
SEND 100% FROM 56 TO 59
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 129
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 130
BUILD 27
Reply
Five provinces short of the 70% line, so I'm taking the cheapest targets: Mauritania, Bosnia, Albania and Sri Lanka. Each send is sized to beat its current cost with a margin.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 56 TO 59
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 129
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 82 TO 130
BUILD 27
</orders>
806:359468%
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 28
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 19
SEND 50% FROM 0 TO 2
SEND 50% FROM 97 TO 59
SEND 50% FROM 18 TO 10
BUILD 41
Reply
the besieged Germany, and make the home capital harder to take.

- **Albania capital (28):** cost 10 against 7 defenders. Sending half of Serbia's 82 troops.
- **Norway (19):** UK's capital, cost 25. A quarter of Russia's 2632 is far more than enough.
- **Mexico capital (2):** cost 60. Half of USA's 1462 troops is enough, and it would take out a 5-province nation.
- **Mauritania (59):** cost 8, with 7 already inbound. Adding half of Senegal's 32 secures it.
- **Germany (10):** besieged by Argentina with 21 troops. Half of Sweden's 43 reinforces it.
- **Capital upgrade:** Vietnam to Impregnable (400g) to hold our own capital against any counterattack.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 28
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 19
SEND 50% FROM 0 TO 2
SEND 50% FROM 97 TO 59
SEND 50% FROM 18 TO 10
BUILD 41
</orders>
816:409468%
SEND 75% FROM 109,129 TO 26
SEND 75% FROM 56,97 TO 59
SEND 75% FROM 10,18 TO 125
BUILD 0
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 109,129 TO 26
SEND 75% FROM 56,97 TO 59
SEND 75% FROM 10,18 TO 125
BUILD 0
</orders>
826:459870%
SEND 25% FROM 0 TO 2
SEND 50% FROM 19 TO 14
SEND 50% FROM 0 TO 105
BUILD 19
BUILD 0 A
Reply
Holding 98 of 139 provinces is exactly the 70% threshold (97.3 rounds up to 98), so one lost province would break the hold. I'll take cheap captures to build a buffer. Mexico's capital (cost 12) is the cheapest target, Netherlands (cost 56) is reachable from Norway's garrison, and Cuba (cost 72) can be reached from USA's large army. I'll also develop Norway's walls and USA's arms complex to strengthen the border provinces.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 0 TO 2
SEND 50% FROM 19 TO 14
SEND 50% FROM 0 TO 105
BUILD 19
BUILD 0 A
</orders>
836:509870%
SEND 50% FROM 2 TO 105
SEND 50% FROM 2 TO 114
BUILD 19
Reply
Holding 70.5% with 5s of the 15s hold left, so I'm prioritising stability. Mexico's muster has spare troops to take two adjacent Mexican provinces, and Norway gets its fortress upgrade ahead of the incoming Argentine march.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 2 TO 105
SEND 50% FROM 2 TO 114
BUILD 19
</orders>
846:559971%
SEND 50% FROM 2 TO 114
BUILD 19 B
BUILD 105
Reply
Holding 99 of 139 provinces, we're above the 98 needed for 70%, with 10s of the 15s hold done. The priority is to keep the count above 98. I'll take the cheap Guatemala capture from Mexico, shore up besieged Norway, and develop Cuba's drydocks.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 2 TO 114
BUILD 19 B
BUILD 105
</orders>