NATIONS ROYALE BENCHMARK · EASY

Claude Sonnet 5.5 as PHL, Easy war 3

Won at 3:41 of game time, holding 105 provinces, 76% of the world, after 45 decisions and 5 refused orders. The game's reference player won at 2:54 on the same war. All of Claude Sonnet 5.5's wars.

RESULTWon
GAME TIME3:41
HELD105 · 76%
DECISIONS45
REFUSED5 of 173
MODEL TIME4.6 min
COST$0.849 (API-equivalent)
TOKENS IN / OUT175,439 / 27,500
REQUESTS45
Share of the world at each decisionThe share of the world's provinces it held each time the war paused. Dashed lines mark the 70% seal and what the game's reference player held at the end of the same war.
0%20%40%60%80%051015Reference 80%Seal 70%Game minutes

The game's players on this war

PlayerResultHeldGame time
Claude Sonnet 5.5Won76%3:41
Reference playerWon80%2:54
Reference on the model's clockWon76%7:11
Sharp personaWon76%4:34
Median personaWon76%9:18
Tourist personaWon80%9:37

Every decision

What it held when the war paused, the orders it gave, and what the game refused and why. The war file carries an arcade-session/1 envelope: the war key and this order stream replay this exact war at Nations Royale commit e426bd2.

DecisionClockHeldOrders
10:0011%
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 82
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 104
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 138
BUILD 43
Reply
I'm taking the three neutral provinces first and developing the capital with Drydocks. Malaysia goes first because it's the strongest of the three. Each order sends 25% of the remaining garrison, which still beats each neutral's troops.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 82
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 104
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 138
BUILD 43
</orders>
20:0543%
BUILD 138
BUILD 104
BUILD 82
SEND 50% FROM 43 TO 104
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 138
BUILD 104
BUILD 82
SEND 50% FROM 43 TO 104
</orders>
30:1043%
SEND 100% FROM 104 TO 93
BUILD 138refused: not enough gold for TAIWAN#138 (80, you have 19)
Reply
I'm taking Laos (93) from Cambodia (104). It holds 46 troops and Cambodia can send 58, so the attack should succeed. I'm also trying to develop Taiwan's workshops (138) with my 19 gold, though that may not be enough to cover the cost.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 104 TO 93
BUILD 138
</orders>
40:1543%
SEND 75% FROM 82,104 TO 93
Reply
I'm sending 75% of Malaysia and Cambodia to take Laos, a non-capital Vietnamese province holding 28 troops. About 45 troops should arrive, enough to beat it while leaving some garrison behind. I'm skipping BUILD because 23 gold can't cover the 80 cost.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 82,104 TO 93
</orders>
50:2054%
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 67
BUILD 138refused: not enough gold for TAIWAN#138 (80, you have 34)
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 67
BUILD 138
</orders>
60:2554%
SEND 50% FROM 43,82,104,93 TO 42
BUILD 93
Reply
I'm attacking Thailand's capital (42), which has 36 troops and costs 44 to take. Half of the garrisons in provinces 43, 82, 104 and 93 should send about 115 troops, well over what it needs. Holding the capital until the countdown ends should also bring Thailand's other province, Myanmar, with it. I'm also building the Stone Walls upgrade on Laos (93) for 35 gold, which I can afford with 39.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 43,82,104,93 TO 42
BUILD 93
</orders>
70:3064%
SEND 75% FROM 138 TO 40
SEND 100% FROM 104,93,82 TO 41
Reply
I'm sending two attacks and leaving the rest of the garrisons in place.

- **S. Korea (40):** Taiwan sends 75% (about 52 troops) against a cost of 35. This takes a capital that Japan is already sieging.
- **Vietnam (41):** Cambodia, Laos and Malaysia send everything they can spare, about 85 troops against a cost of 73. The margin is thin, and the Malaysia troops cross by sea.
- **Thailand's capital (42):** it stays untouched with its 79 troops, so the 17-second countdown can finish and Thailand folds to me.

I'm not building anything, since 17 gold likely won't cover it.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 138 TO 40
SEND 100% FROM 104,93,82 TO 41
</orders>
80:3575%
SEND 100% FROM 138 TO 40
BUILD 138refused: not enough gold for TAIWAN#138 (80, you have 34)
Reply
I'm sending all of Taiwan's garrison at South Korea's capital. It has 25 troops and Taiwan can send about 31, so the attack should win. I'm keeping Thailand's capital held so it folds in 12s. Myanmar should fall with it, so I'm not spending troops there. I'm also spending the 34 gold on developing Taiwan, though I don't know what a build costs.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 138 TO 40
BUILD 138
</orders>
90:4086%
BUILD 40
Reply
I'm holding both captured capitals so their countdowns finish. Thailand folds in 7s, S. Korea in 16s, and each fall should bring their remaining provinces with it. So I'm not attacking N. Korea or Myanmar now. I'm spending the 47 gold on Workshops in S. Korea (35g, +13 gold/min).

<orders>
BUILD 40
</orders>
100:4586%
SEND 75% FROM 42 TO 67
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 67
Reply
I'm attacking Myanmar, the one weak neighbour (42 troops, cost 43), with 75% of Thailand's garrison and 50% of Laos's. That sends roughly 71 troops. I'm leaving the two captured capitals alone so they fold on their countdowns. Gold is only 19, so I'm not building this turn.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 42 TO 67
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 67
</orders>
110:5096%
SEND 100% FROM 40 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 104,42 TO 67
BUILD 67
Reply
Taking N. Korea from S. Korea's capital while its countdown runs, and massing troops at Myanmar for a strike on Bangladesh's capital.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 40 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 104,42 TO 67
BUILD 67
</orders>
120:55107%
SEND 100% FROM 67 TO 37
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 67
Reply
I'm attacking Bangladesh's capital (province 37) from Myanmar (67). It holds 56 troops with a cost of 68, and I'm sending about 89, so taking it should eliminate the nation. I'm also sending Laos's troops to Myanmar to backfill it.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 67 TO 37
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 67
</orders>
131:00118%
SEND 50% FROM 43,138,41,93,102 TO 38
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 43,138,41,93,102 TO 38
</orders>
141:05129%
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 90
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 99
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 134
BUILD 38
Reply
I'm using China's 113 troops to take three weak neutral neighbours: Kyrgyzstan (cost 14), Tajikistan (cost 14) and Bhutan (cost 10). Each 25% send covers the cost. Mongolia (cost 23) and Kazakhstan (cost 36) would stretch China too thin, so I'm leaving them for now. With 51 gold, I'm building a muster ground at China (35g) to keep troops streaming to the front.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 90
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 99
SEND 25% FROM 38 TO 134
BUILD 38
</orders>
151:101511%
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 50
SEND 75% FROM 104,41,93 TO 38
BUILD 37
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 50
SEND 75% FROM 104,41,93 TO 38
BUILD 37
</orders>
161:151612%
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 36
SEND 100% FROM 90 TO 70
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 36
SEND 100% FROM 90 TO 70
</orders>
171:201712%
SEND 75% FROM 38,99 TO 36
BUILD 70
Reply
Pakistan's capital (36) holds only 18 troops and I have 62 within reach. I'm sending 75% from Tajikistan (99) and China (38) to take it, which should knock Pakistan out of the war. I'm also developing Uzbekistan (70) into a war camp with the 35 gold available.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 38,99 TO 36
BUILD 70
</orders>
181:251813%
SEND 50% FROM 36 TO 51
SEND 100% FROM 90 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 48
BUILD 42
Reply
I'm keeping the Pakistan capital (36) garrisoned so it folds in 16s, and using the surplus troops on Iran and Kazakhstan. I skipped Oman because 25% of what's left at 36 after the Iran order would only tie its cost of 14, and ties go to the defender.

- **Iran (51):** 50% from 36 sends about 55 troops against a cost of 43.
- **Kazakhstan (48):** 100% from 90 plus 50% from 38 sends about 42 troops against a cost of 29.
- **Thailand (42):** I'm spending 35 of the 55 gold on a muster ground there.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 36 TO 51
SEND 100% FROM 90 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 48
BUILD 42
</orders>
191:302014%
SEND 75% FROM 37,67,134 TO 35
BUILD 50
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 37,67,134 TO 35
BUILD 50
</orders>
201:352014%
SEND 100% FROM 38,37,134,67 TO 35
SEND 75% FROM 51 TO 87
SEND 50% FROM 90 TO 48
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 38,37,134,67 TO 35
SEND 75% FROM 51 TO 87
SEND 50% FROM 90 TO 48
</orders>
211:402216%
SEND 25% FROM 35 TO 103
SEND 25% FROM 35 TO 130
BUILD 40
Reply
I'm finishing off INDIA by taking NEPAL and SRI LANKA from the capital garrison at 35, which still keeps plenty of troops there. I'm also spending my 86 gold on factory lines at S. KOREA (40) for more income. I'm holding everywhere else so PAKISTAN's capital folds in 1s and INDIA's in 19s.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 35 TO 103
SEND 25% FROM 35 TO 130
BUILD 40
</orders>
221:452417%
SEND 50% FROM 40,48,50,102 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 70 TO 74
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 78
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 40,48,50,102 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 70 TO 74
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 78
</orders>
231:502820%
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 117
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 122
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 121
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 123
BUILD 138
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 117
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 122
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 121
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 123
BUILD 138
</orders>
241:552921%
SEND 50% FROM 78 TO 115
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 75% FROM 103,50,65,38 TO 17
BUILD 48
BUILD 35refused: not enough gold for INDIA#35 (35, you have 34)
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 78 TO 115
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 75% FROM 103,50,65,38 TO 17
BUILD 48
BUILD 35
</orders>
252:003525%
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 85
SEND 50% FROM 78 TO 58
BUILD 74
BUILD 78
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 85
SEND 50% FROM 78 TO 58
BUILD 74
BUILD 78
</orders>
262:053727%
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 100% FROM 58 TO 71
BUILD 17
BUILD 39
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 100% FROM 58 TO 71
BUILD 17
BUILD 39
</orders>
272:103928%
SEND 50% FROM 48,74 TO 110
SEND 100% FROM 115 TO 52
SEND 75% FROM 39,138,40 TO 17
BUILD 122
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 48,74 TO 110
SEND 100% FROM 115 TO 52
SEND 75% FROM 39,138,40 TO 17
BUILD 122
</orders>
282:154230%
SEND 75% FROM 71 TO 92
SEND 75% FROM 52 TO 72
SEND 75% FROM 17,110,121,51 TO 22
BUILD 58
BUILD 117
Reply
I'm taking the two cheap neutral provinces and striking Turkey's capital, with two cheap developments alongside.

- **Uganda and Central Africa:** 71 and 52 each send 75%, enough to clear the costs of 17 and 18.
- **Turkey's capital (22):** it holds 40 troops at a cost of 48. Russia, Azerbaijan, Georgia and Iran send about 240 combined, so the capital should fall and take Turkey's four provinces with it.
- **Development:** Ethiopia gets Stone Walls and Lithuania gets a War Camp, 35g each out of my 82g.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 71 TO 92
SEND 75% FROM 52 TO 72
SEND 75% FROM 17,110,121,51 TO 22
BUILD 58
BUILD 117
</orders>
292:204532%
SEND 50% FROM 117 TO 15
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 58 TO 47
BUILD 122
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 117 TO 15
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 58 TO 47
BUILD 122
</orders>
302:254532%
SEND 75% FROM 17,85,117 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 58,75,71 TO 47
BUILD 116
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 17,85,117 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 58,75,71 TO 47
BUILD 116
</orders>
312:304734%
SEND 25% FROM 72 TO 84
SEND 25% FROM 72 TO 79
SEND 25% FROM 47 TO 63
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 52 TO 53
BUILD 72
BUILD 22
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 72 TO 84
SEND 25% FROM 72 TO 79
SEND 25% FROM 47 TO 63
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 52 TO 53
BUILD 72
BUILD 22
</orders>
322:355237%
SEND 75% FROM 15 TO 10
SEND 100% FROM 52 TO 29
SEND 100% FROM 115 TO 34
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 49
BUILD 116
BUILD 71
BUILD 52refused: not enough gold for SUDAN#52 (35, you have 29)
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 15 TO 10
SEND 100% FROM 52 TO 29
SEND 100% FROM 115 TO 34
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 49
BUILD 116
BUILD 71
BUILD 52
</orders>
332:405842%
SEND 50% FROM 34 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 111
SEND 75% FROM 49 TO 66
SEND 75% FROM 84 TO 55
SEND 50% FROM 53 TO 101
BUILD 34
BUILD 10
BUILD 47
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 34 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 111
SEND 75% FROM 49 TO 66
SEND 75% FROM 84 TO 55
SEND 50% FROM 53 TO 101
BUILD 34
BUILD 10
BUILD 47
</orders>
342:456345%
SEND 75% FROM 53,79 TO 57
SEND 75% FROM 63,111 TO 64
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 83
SEND 50% FROM 72 TO 69
BUILD 10
BUILD 29
Reply
he cheap neutral provinces and keep both captured capitals in place. Germany and Poland are held with no new orders from them. Poland folds in 2s and Germany in 13s, while the French column due at Germany in 1s should not be enough against its 69 troops.

- **Niger:** 75% from Libya and Cameroon, about 52 troops against a cost of 16.
- **Mozambique:** 75% from Tanzania and Malawi, about 30 against a cost of 18.
- **Zimbabwe:** 50% from South Sudan, about 113 against a cost of 19.
- **Botswana:** 50% from Central Africa, about 66 against a cost of 18.
- **Development:** Germany's factory lines (80g) and Egypt's muster grounds (35g), 115g of the 141 I hold.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 53,79 TO 57
SEND 75% FROM 63,111 TO 64
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 83
SEND 50% FROM 72 TO 69
BUILD 10
BUILD 29
</orders>
352:506647%
SEND 75% FROM 57 TO 113
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 26
SEND 75% FROM 115 TO 54
BUILD 123
BUILD 24
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 57 TO 113
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 26
SEND 75% FROM 115 TO 54
BUILD 123
BUILD 24
</orders>
362:557050%
SEND 75% FROM 22 TO 21
SEND 100% FROM 54 TO 30
SEND 75% FROM 64 TO 73
BUILD 83
BUILD 66
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 22 TO 21
SEND 100% FROM 54 TO 30
SEND 75% FROM 64 TO 73
BUILD 83
BUILD 66
</orders>
373:007453%
SEND 100% FROM 53 TO 33
SEND 50% FROM 57,79,54 TO 30
SEND 50% FROM 55,66 TO 62
SEND 100% FROM 83,69 TO 31
BUILD 40 B
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 53 TO 33
SEND 50% FROM 57,79,54 TO 30
SEND 50% FROM 55,66 TO 62
SEND 100% FROM 83,69 TO 31
BUILD 40 B
</orders>
383:057655%
SEND 100% FROM 62 TO 31
SEND 75% FROM 30,84 TO 91
SEND 100% FROM 21,22 TO 106
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 14
SEND 50% FROM 113 TO 127
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 129
BUILD 113
BUILD 63
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 62 TO 31
SEND 75% FROM 30,84 TO 91
SEND 100% FROM 21,22 TO 106
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 14
SEND 50% FROM 113 TO 127
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 129
BUILD 113
BUILD 63
</orders>
393:108360%
SEND 50% FROM 33 TO 56
SEND 50% FROM 33 TO 59
SEND 75% FROM 113,57 TO 88
SEND 75% FROM 10 TO 128
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 109
SEND 75% FROM 111,54,31 TO 113
Reply
r its current cost:

- **Mali (cost 49):** 50% from Algeria, 118 troops.
- **Mauritania (cost 52):** 50% of Algeria's remaining garrison, about 59 troops.
- **Burkina Faso (cost 51):** 75% from Benin and Niger, about 97 troops together.
- **Switzerland (cost 50):** 75% from Germany, 72 troops.
- **Austria (cost 65):** 75% from Hungary, 70 troops. This is a thin margin against its stone walls.

The last order moves 75% of Malawi, Chad and S. Africa up to Benin to prepare an attack on Ghana's capital next.

Algeria keeps over 100 troops after both sends, which should be enough to hold its capital through the 18s countdown.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 33 TO 56
SEND 50% FROM 33 TO 59
SEND 75% FROM 113,57 TO 88
SEND 75% FROM 10 TO 128
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 109
SEND 75% FROM 111,54,31 TO 113
</orders>
403:158763%
SEND 25% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 75% FROM 56 TO 89
SEND 75% FROM 33 TO 59
SEND 100% FROM 88 TO 86
SEND 100% FROM 22,106 TO 23
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 75% FROM 56 TO 89
SEND 75% FROM 33 TO 59
SEND 100% FROM 88 TO 86
SEND 100% FROM 22,106 TO 23
</orders>
413:209266%
SEND 75% FROM 89 TO 126
SEND 75% FROM 23 TO 133
SEND 100% FROM 10 TO 9
SEND 100% FROM 59 TO 13
SEND 75% FROM 129,106,26,21,24 TO 27
BUILD 43
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 89 TO 126
SEND 75% FROM 23 TO 133
SEND 100% FROM 10 TO 9
SEND 100% FROM 59 TO 13
SEND 75% FROM 129,106,26,21,24 TO 27
BUILD 43
</orders>
423:259669%
SEND 75% FROM 10 TO 25
SEND 100% FROM 23 TO 133
SEND 50% FROM 43 TO 76
SEND 100% FROM 14 TO 135
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 10 TO 25
SEND 100% FROM 23 TO 133
SEND 50% FROM 43 TO 76
SEND 100% FROM 14 TO 135
</orders>
433:309971%
SEND 75% FROM 127,86,88 TO 46
SEND 50% FROM 126,89 TO 118
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 135
SEND 50% FROM 76 TO 136
BUILD 40
BUILD 10 B
BUILD 43
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 127,86,88 TO 46
SEND 50% FROM 126,89 TO 118
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 135
SEND 50% FROM 76 TO 136
BUILD 40
BUILD 10 B
BUILD 43
</orders>
443:3510374%
SEND 75% FROM 23,85,15 TO 16
SEND 75% FROM 27,21,26 TO 28
BUILD 10
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 23,85,15 TO 16
SEND 75% FROM 27,21,26 TO 28
BUILD 10
</orders>
453:4010475%
SEND 75% FROM 17,124,24 TO 16
BUILD 83
Reply
I'm holding 104 provinces against the 98 needed, and the 15-second countdown is at 14s. I'm making only low-risk moves so I don't lose ground. Ukraine's capital costs only 7 troops, so I'm sending a strong force from Russia (17) and Slovakia (124) to take it. I'm also spending gold on Zimbabwe's upgrade.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 17,124,24 TO 16
BUILD 83
</orders>