NATIONS ROYALE BENCHMARK · EASY

Claude Haiku 5.5 as PHL, Easy war 3

Won at 3:30 of game time, holding 102 provinces, 73% of the world, after 42 decisions and 2 refused orders. The game's reference player won at 2:54 on the same war. All of Claude Haiku 5.5's wars.

RESULTWon
GAME TIME3:30
HELD102 · 73%
DECISIONS42
REFUSED2 of 189
MODEL TIME7.3 min
COST$0.063 (API-equivalent)
TOKENS IN / OUT163,425 / 71,709
REQUESTS42
Share of the world at each decisionThe share of the world's provinces it held each time the war paused. Dashed lines mark the 70% seal and what the game's reference player held at the end of the same war.
0%20%40%60%80%051015Reference 80%Seal 70%Game minutes

The game's players on this war

PlayerResultHeldGame time
Claude Haiku 5.5Won73%3:30
Reference playerWon80%2:54
Reference on the model's clockWon76%7:11
Sharp personaWon76%4:34
Median personaWon76%9:18
Tourist personaWon80%9:37

Every decision

What it held when the war paused, the orders it gave, and what the game refused and why. The war file carries an arcade-session/1 envelope: the war key and this order stream replay this exact war at Nations Royale commit e426bd2.

DecisionClockHeldOrders
10:0011%
BUILD 43
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 138
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 104
SEND 50% FROM 43 TO 82
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 43
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 138
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 104
SEND 50% FROM 43 TO 82
</orders>
20:0543%
SEND 75% FROM 104 TO 93
BUILD 138
BUILD 82
Reply
Cambodia (19 troops) can take neutral Laos (cost 9) with a 75% send, which should leave about 5 behind. I'm also developing Taiwan for gold income and Malaysia for a harbor, which keeps about 51 gold in reserve.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 104 TO 93
BUILD 138
BUILD 82
</orders>
30:1054%
SEND 75% FROM 104 TO 93
BUILD 93 A
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 104 TO 93
BUILD 93 A
</orders>
40:1554%
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 67
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 104
Reply
Myanmar is the only neutral next to us and is cheap to take. Laos sending 75% (27 troops) clears its cost of 20. I'm also moving some capital troops into Cambodia so it can threaten Thailand or Vietnam later.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 67
SEND 25% FROM 43 TO 104
</orders>
50:2064%
SEND 100% FROM 138 TO 38
BUILD 104 A
Reply
Taking China's capital (38) needs 51 troops, and Taiwan's 66 can send 65 at 100%. That's enough to eliminate China, though Taiwan will be left nearly empty. I'm also spending the 35 gold on Cambodia's muster grounds to raise future garrison output.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 138 TO 38
BUILD 104 A
</orders>
60:2575%
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 134
SEND 75% FROM 43 TO 42
SEND 100% FROM 104 TO 42
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 41
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 134
SEND 75% FROM 43 TO 42
SEND 100% FROM 104 TO 42
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 41
</orders>
70:3096%
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 99
SEND 100% FROM 67,134 TO 35
BUILD 134
Reply
Taking Tajikistan with 75% of China, and India's capital with the two western provinces. I'm holding Thailand back because it's over its cap.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 99
SEND 100% FROM 67,134 TO 35
BUILD 134
</orders>
80:35118%
SEND 50% FROM 42 TO 104
RALLY 104 TO 90refused: a muster reinforces a province of yours
Reply
Holding India's capital (35) is the priority, so I'm not moving its garrison. Thailand has the largest idle reserve, so I'm shifting half of it to the Cambodia muster and aiming that muster at neutral Kyrgyzstan, which is the cheapest nearby target.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 42 TO 104
RALLY 104 TO 90
</orders>
90:40118%
SEND 75% FROM 104 TO 41
SEND 75% FROM 99 TO 90
Reply
I'm committing a larger force to Vietnam's capital, where my siege already stands, and taking the neutral province at Kyrgyzstan with a margin over its cost. India's capital stays garrisoned while its countdown runs.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 104 TO 41
SEND 75% FROM 99 TO 90
</orders>
100:45139%
SEND 75% FROM 41 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 35
BUILD 38
Reply
Gold covers one development, so I'm building the China muster, which feeds the front. I'm also moving surplus interior troops toward the northern border: Vietnam's 75 (over its cap) goes to China, and half of Laos goes to India.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 41 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 35
BUILD 38
</orders>
110:501410%
SEND 75% FROM 67,35 TO 37
SEND 75% FROM 138 TO 40
SEND 75% FROM 90,99 TO 70
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 50
BUILD 42
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 67,35 TO 37
SEND 75% FROM 138 TO 40
SEND 75% FROM 90,99 TO 70
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 50
BUILD 42
</orders>
120:551914%
SEND 100% FROM 70 TO 74
SEND 75% FROM 103,93 TO 90
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 90
BUILD 40
BUILD 70
RALLY 38 TO 48refused: a muster reinforces a province of yours
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 70 TO 74
SEND 75% FROM 103,93 TO 90
SEND 50% FROM 104 TO 90
BUILD 40
BUILD 70
RALLY 38 TO 48
</orders>
131:002014%
SEND 75% FROM 90,38 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 134,130 TO 99
SEND 50% FROM 104,67 TO 35
Reply
I'm taking Kazakhstan (neutral, cost 36) with an overwhelming 65 troops. I'm also moving interior troops toward Tajikistan to stage an attack on Afghanistan, and reinforcing India on the Pakistan border. The capital stays untouched.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 90,38 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 134,130 TO 99
SEND 50% FROM 104,67 TO 35
</orders>
141:052115%
SEND 100% FROM 40 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 99,70 TO 65
SEND 100% FROM 43,82 TO 44
SEND 100% FROM 90 TO 48
RALLY 70 TO 65
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 40 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 99,70 TO 65
SEND 100% FROM 43,82 TO 44
SEND 100% FROM 90 TO 48
RALLY 70 TO 65
</orders>
151:102216%
SEND 50% FROM 70 TO 65
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 110
SEND 50% FROM 42 TO 44
BUILD 48
Reply
Taking Afghanistan with a half-share from Uzbekistan, and hitting Azerbaijan and Indonesia with half-shares from the two provinces that can reach them by sea. Kazakhstan is over its cap at 120/48, so I'm developing it with supply depots to raise the cap.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 70 TO 65
SEND 50% FROM 48 TO 110
SEND 50% FROM 42 TO 44
BUILD 48
</orders>
161:152518%
SEND 75% FROM 44 TO 76
SEND 75% FROM 65,74 TO 51
BUILD 50
RALLY 70 TO 51
Reply
Papua is the cheapest target: 75% of Indonesia's 105 troops (about 79) beats its cost of 57. Iran is next: 75% from Afghanistan and Turkmenistan (about 83) beats its cost of 66. Gold covers one development, so I'm building the War Camp at Mongolia for future offense. Uzbekistan's war camp is pointed at Iran to reinforce that push.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 44 TO 76
SEND 75% FROM 65,74 TO 51
BUILD 50
RALLY 70 TO 51
</orders>
171:202619%
SEND 75% FROM 40,138 TO 39
BUILD 110
Reply
The clearest gain is Japan's capital (cost 89, holds 74). I'm sending 75% from both coastal provinces that border it, which gives about 141 troops against 74. Azerbaijan's workshops add gold and raise its cap, so I'm developing it too. Papua's siege is already running, so I'm leaving it alone.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 40,138 TO 39
BUILD 110
</orders>
181:252820%
BUILD 110 A
SEND 75% FROM 35,38,99,65 TO 36
RALLY 50 TO 22
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 110 A
SEND 75% FROM 35,38,99,65 TO 36
RALLY 50 TO 22
</orders>
191:302921%
SEND 100% FROM 35,99,65 TO 36
SEND 75% FROM 110 TO 121
BUILD 74
SEND 100% FROM 74 TO 110
Reply
Pakistan's capital (36) is the cheapest big prize: it holds 40 troops and costs 49 to take, and I already have siege on it. I'll commit the three neighbouring provinces that border it, keeping one troop in each. Azerbaijan's 75% push should take Georgia (cost 50). I'll also spend the 41 gold on Turkmenistan's supply depots and move its overflow of 100 troops up behind the Azerbaijan front.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 35,99,65 TO 36
SEND 75% FROM 110 TO 121
BUILD 74
SEND 100% FROM 74 TO 110
</orders>
201:353122%
SEND 75% FROM 36 TO 87
SEND 75% FROM 110 TO 22
SEND 50% FROM 138,65 TO 22
BUILD 36
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 36 TO 87
SEND 75% FROM 110 TO 22
SEND 50% FROM 138,65 TO 22
BUILD 36
</orders>
211:403324%
BUILD 40
BUILD 65
SEND 50% FROM 45 TO 81
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 40
BUILD 65
SEND 50% FROM 45 TO 81
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
</orders>
221:453626%
SEND 75% FROM 75 TO 78
SEND 50% FROM 22 TO 106
SEND 75% FROM 38,50,48,39,40,102,110,121 TO 17
BUILD 138
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 75 TO 78
SEND 50% FROM 22 TO 106
SEND 75% FROM 38,50,48,39,40,102,110,121 TO 17
BUILD 138
</orders>
231:503827%
BUILD 87
SEND 75% FROM 45 TO 22
RALLY 50 TO 77
RALLY 36 TO 96
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 87
SEND 75% FROM 45 TO 22
RALLY 50 TO 77
RALLY 36 TO 96
</orders>
241:553928%
BUILD 17 A
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 85
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 122
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 75% FROM 75 TO 58
SEND 50% FROM 40,110,138 TO 17
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 17 A
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 85
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 122
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 75% FROM 75 TO 58
SEND 50% FROM 40,110,138 TO 17
</orders>
252:004029%
SEND 75% FROM 78 TO 34
SEND 75% FROM 75 TO 47
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 115
SEND 50% FROM 58 TO 71
BUILD 78
Reply
Seven attacks plus one development. Each attack is sized above its current cost, and I'm leaving Turkey's capital 22 untouched because it already folds to me.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 78 TO 34
SEND 75% FROM 75 TO 47
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 115
SEND 50% FROM 58 TO 71
BUILD 78
</orders>
262:054935%
SEND 25% FROM 58 TO 47
SEND 50% FROM 78,77 TO 34
SEND 50% FROM 115 TO 52
BUILD 17
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 58 TO 47
SEND 50% FROM 78,77 TO 34
SEND 50% FROM 115 TO 52
BUILD 17
</orders>
272:105338%
SEND 50% FROM 47 TO 63
SEND 75% FROM 71 TO 72
SEND 50% FROM 85 TO 117
BUILD 34
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 47 TO 63
SEND 75% FROM 71 TO 72
SEND 50% FROM 85 TO 117
BUILD 34
</orders>
282:155640%
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 100% FROM 22 TO 21
BUILD 22 A
BUILD 106 A
Reply
Turkey (22) and Russia (17) are over their caps, so I'm spending their surplus on Greece and Latvia. Then I'm developing Turkey into a war camp and Bulgaria into stone walls.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 100% FROM 22 TO 21
BUILD 22 A
BUILD 106 A
</orders>
292:205640%
SEND 25% FROM 22 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 72 TO 84
SEND 50% FROM 47 TO 92
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 49
SEND 75% FROM 52 TO 54
BUILD 71
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 22 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 72 TO 84
SEND 50% FROM 47 TO 92
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 49
SEND 75% FROM 52 TO 54
BUILD 71
</orders>
302:256245%
SEND 50% FROM 49 TO 55
SEND 25% FROM 72 TO 79
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 66
SEND 50% FROM 21 TO 53
BUILD 72
BUILD 68
BUILD 116
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 49 TO 55
SEND 25% FROM 72 TO 79
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 66
SEND 50% FROM 21 TO 53
BUILD 72
BUILD 68
BUILD 116
</orders>
312:306647%
SEND 25% FROM 71 TO 83
SEND 50% FROM 72 TO 69
SEND 25% FROM 110 TO 57
SEND 75% FROM 22 TO 23
SEND 50% FROM 68 TO 18
BUILD 52
BUILD 116 A
Reply
I'm taking the cheap neutral provinces and the over-cap garrisons on the Romania and Sweden fronts, then spending gold on Sudan's depots and Latvia's factory lines.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 71 TO 83
SEND 50% FROM 72 TO 69
SEND 25% FROM 110 TO 57
SEND 75% FROM 22 TO 23
SEND 50% FROM 68 TO 18
BUILD 52
BUILD 116 A
</orders>
322:356647%
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 23
SEND 100% FROM 15 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 68 TO 18
SEND 75% FROM 55 TO 62
BUILD 15
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 23
SEND 100% FROM 15 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 68 TO 18
SEND 75% FROM 55 TO 62
BUILD 15
</orders>
332:407353%
SEND 50% FROM 63 TO 64
SEND 75% FROM 66 TO 111
SEND 50% FROM 23 TO 133
SEND 50% FROM 54 TO 57
BUILD 63
BUILD 18
BUILD 71
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 63 TO 64
SEND 75% FROM 66 TO 111
SEND 50% FROM 23 TO 133
SEND 50% FROM 54 TO 57
BUILD 63
BUILD 18
BUILD 71
</orders>
342:457755%
SEND 100% FROM 15 TO 124
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 73
SEND 100% FROM 66 TO 57
SEND 100% FROM 71 TO 17
RALLY 18 TO 125
BUILD 66
BUILD 77
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 15 TO 124
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 73
SEND 100% FROM 66 TO 57
SEND 100% FROM 71 TO 17
RALLY 18 TO 125
BUILD 66
BUILD 77
</orders>
352:507856%
SEND 50% FROM 24 TO 124
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 88
SEND 75% FROM 79,84 TO 91
SEND 75% FROM 15 TO 25
BUILD 83 A
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 24 TO 124
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 88
SEND 75% FROM 79,84 TO 91
SEND 75% FROM 15 TO 25
BUILD 83 A
</orders>
362:558259%
SEND 25% FROM 57 TO 56
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 10
SEND 75% FROM 24,25 TO 109
SEND 75% FROM 18 TO 125
SEND 50% FROM 62 TO 31
BUILD 57
BUILD 62
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 57 TO 56
SEND 50% FROM 15 TO 10
SEND 75% FROM 24,25 TO 109
SEND 75% FROM 18 TO 125
SEND 50% FROM 62 TO 31
BUILD 57
BUILD 62
</orders>
373:008763%
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 89
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 135
SEND 50% FROM 17,133 TO 16
SEND 75% FROM 88 TO 127
SEND 100% FROM 31 TO 88
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 56
BUILD 57
Reply
Taking Guinea, Belgium, Ukraine's capital and Togo should add several provinces toward the 98 needed. Mali and Germany send half their garrisons at the cheap targets. Russia and Poland stack Ukraine. Burkina Faso takes Togo, and the Mozambique and S. Africa stacks move up to the front.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 89
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 135
SEND 50% FROM 17,133 TO 16
SEND 75% FROM 88 TO 127
SEND 100% FROM 31 TO 88
SEND 50% FROM 64 TO 56
BUILD 57
</orders>
383:059065%
SEND 50% FROM 88 TO 86
SEND 50% FROM 88 TO 113
SEND 100% FROM 57,79 TO 30
SEND 100% FROM 10 TO 14
SEND 75% FROM 135 TO 118
BUILD 88
BUILD 43
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 88 TO 86
SEND 50% FROM 88 TO 113
SEND 100% FROM 57,79 TO 30
SEND 100% FROM 10 TO 14
SEND 75% FROM 135 TO 118
BUILD 88
BUILD 43
</orders>
393:109568%
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 59
SEND 75% FROM 56,89 TO 97
SEND 75% FROM 125 TO 19
SEND 100% FROM 86,88 TO 46
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 59
SEND 75% FROM 56,89 TO 97
SEND 75% FROM 125 TO 19
SEND 100% FROM 86,88 TO 46
</orders>
403:159870%
SEND 75% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 128
BUILD 25
BUILD 57 B
BUILD 17 B
Reply
Holding 98 of 139 provinces is already above the 70% line, so the priority is to keep it and add cheap captures. The plan: take Senegal with 75% of Mali's garrison (19 troops against a cost of 8), take Switzerland with half of Germany's 70 troops (35 against a cost of 28), and develop Czechia for gold. Niger and Russia get the assembly ground upgrade so interior surplus can reach the front.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 128
BUILD 25
BUILD 57 B
BUILD 17 B
</orders>
413:2010173%
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 101
SEND 50% FROM 16 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 125 TO 19
BUILD 16
BUILD 86
BUILD 88
RALLY 88 TO 33
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 57 TO 101
SEND 50% FROM 16 TO 17
SEND 75% FROM 125 TO 19
BUILD 16
BUILD 86
BUILD 88
RALLY 88 TO 33
</orders>
423:2510173%
BUILD 86
BUILD 19
BUILD 59
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 86 TO 57
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 86
BUILD 19
BUILD 59
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 86 TO 57
</orders>