NATIONS ROYALE BENCHMARK · EXTREME

Claude Haiku 5.5 as ALB, Extreme war 2

Lost at 6:33 of game time, holding 0 provinces, 0% of the world, after 79 decisions and 18 refused orders. The game's reference player lost at 4:12 on the same war. All of Claude Haiku 5.5's wars.

RESULTLost
GAME TIME6:33
HELD0 · 0%
DECISIONS79
REFUSED18 of 178
MODEL TIME11.6 min
COST$0.087 (API-equivalent)
TOKENS IN / OUT221,568 / 107,646
REQUESTS79
Share of the world at each decisionThe share of the world's provinces it held each time the war paused. The dashed line marks the 70% seal.
0%20%40%60%051015Seal 70%Game minutes

The game's players on this war

PlayerResultHeldGame time
Claude Haiku 5.5Lost0%6:33
Reference playerLost0%4:12
Reference on the model's clockLost0%2:40
Sharp personaLost0%4:07
Median personaLost0%1:37
Tourist personaLost0%3:24

Every decision

What it held when the war paused, the orders it gave, and what the game refused and why. The war file carries an arcade-session/1 envelope: the war key and this order stream replay this exact war at Nations Royale commit e426bd2.

DecisionClockHeldOrders
10:0011%
BUILD 28
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 26
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 28
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 26
</orders>
20:0521%
SEND 50% FROM 26 TO 129
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 109
BUILD 26
Reply
Croatia is over its cap at 43/22, so it's the province to spend troops from. Bosnia (cost 10) and Austria (cost 13) are neutral and cheap to take. I'm keeping the capital at home, since Greece (61) and Serbia border it. The war camp in Croatia adds garrison and streams troops toward enemies.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 26 TO 129
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 109
BUILD 26
</orders>
30:1043%
SEND 50% FROM 11 TO 26
SEND 25% FROM 28 TO 26
BUILD 11
BUILD 109
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 11 TO 26
SEND 25% FROM 28 TO 26
BUILD 11
BUILD 109
</orders>
40:1554%
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 128
BUILD 26
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 128
BUILD 26
</orders>
50:2064%
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 109
RALLY 26 TO 25
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 109
RALLY 26 TO 25
</orders>
60:2564%
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 109
RALLY 26 TO 25
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 109
RALLY 26 TO 25
</orders>
70:3064%
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 25
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 53
SEND 25% FROM 28 TO 129
RALLY 26 TO 27
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 25
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 53
SEND 25% FROM 28 TO 129
RALLY 26 TO 27
</orders>
80:3564%
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 10
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 25
BUILD 28 Arefused: not enough gold for ALBANIA#28 (150, you have 32)
Reply
Germany's capital (10) has only 6 troops, and 128 can send 11 against that. Czechia (25) is 7 to take, and 109 can send 13 from its 18. Croatia's war camp is already rallying toward Serbia, so I'm leaving that alone. The capital keeps 40 troops, and I'm spending gold on its development for defense.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 10
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 25
BUILD 28 A
</orders>
90:4064%
BUILD 129
Reply
Bosnia's upgrade costs 35 gold and I have 39, so I'll build it now. Stone walls raise its cap and defence. No attack is affordable this turn: every neighbour's cost is above what I can send, and Croatia's war camp is already rallying toward Serbia.

<orders>
BUILD 129
</orders>
100:4554%
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 27
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 27
Reply
Serbia's capital (27) is the best target. It has 23 troops against my 41 committed from the capital, and 41 beats its cost of 34. Bosnia adds a second wave to make the capture certain. Taking Serbia's capital should also lift the siege on Croatia.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 27
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 27
</orders>
110:5064%
BUILD 128
Reply
Serbia (6 troops) faces 17 incoming from Romania, and no reinforcement can arrive in time, so I'm not spending gold there. Switzerland (19 troops, near its cap) is a steadier frontier province against France and Germany, and the fortress upgrade raises its cap and defence. I'm holding the other garrisons where they are, since moving Croatia's or Italy's troops would leave them exposed to Hungary and Austria.

<orders>
BUILD 128
</orders>
120:5564%
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 10
RALLY 26 TO 106
Reply
Albania's capital and border provinces are well garrisoned, so I'll take the cheapest enemy target. Germany's capital at 10 costs 9 troops, and Italy's 75% share (about 14 troops) should clear it. I'm also aiming Croatia's war camp at Bulgaria (106), which is the next weak border. Switzerland and the capital stay put as defence.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 10
RALLY 26 TO 106
</orders>
131:0075%
BUILD 27
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 27
</orders>
141:0564%
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 106
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 11
RALLY 26 TO 109
Reply
Key facts: Bulgaria (106) is held by Romania with 9 troops and borders Serbia (27), which has 25. Sending 50% gives 12 troops against a cost of 9. Greece's capital (21) costs 21, and the capital (28) can send 75%, or 39 troops. Italy (11) has only 4 troops on a long exposed border, so I'm reinforcing it from the interior. Croatia's war camp is redirected at Austria (109), which costs 24, so its stream builds toward that target.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 106
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 11
RALLY 26 TO 109
</orders>
151:1075%
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 109
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 27
BUILD 21
Reply
Croatia has a full war camp, so I'm using 75% of it to take Austria. That's about 20 troops against the 18 defenders, and the 3 marching troops add to that. The capital sends half its garrison to Serbia to break Hungary's siege, and I'm developing Greece into a harbor with the 35 gold I have.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 109
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 27
BUILD 21
</orders>
161:1586%
SEND 100% FROM 26,27,109 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 129,28 TO 27
Reply
Hungary's capital (24) is the best target. Its cost is 33, and I can field 39 from Croatia (26), Serbia (27) and Austria (109) at 100%. The interior provinces then reinforce Serbia, which borders Romania and Bulgaria.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 26,27,109 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 129,28 TO 27
</orders>
171:2096%
SEND 75% FROM 28,129 TO 24
BUILD 109
Reply
Hungary's capital (24) is holding only 9 troops, and its 18-second countdown is running. I'm sending reinforcements from the two interior provinces, Albania's capital (28) and Bosnia (129), which together can spare about 28 troops. I'm also developing Austria (109), which is weakly held and exposed to Germany and France.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 28,129 TO 24
BUILD 109
</orders>
181:2596%
SEND 50% FROM 11 TO 109
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 21
RALLY 26 TO 106
BUILD 11refused: not enough gold for ITALY#11 (80, you have 30)
Reply
Hungary's capital (24) is the priority. It folds in 13s if I keep it, and it is surrounded by Ukraine, Romania, Czechia, and Poland, so I'm not sending anything out of it. Italy is full at 32/32 and wasting output, so I'm moving half of it to Austria, which is weak at 11/25 and next to Czechia. Serbia sends half its troops to relieve Greece, which is under siege by Turkey. Croatia's war camp is aimed at Bulgaria, which is the province besieging Greece. Italy also gets a development order, since gold is idle.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 11 TO 109
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 21
RALLY 26 TO 106
BUILD 11
</orders>
191:3096%
BUILD 24
SEND 50% FROM 109 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 24
Reply
Hungary's capital (24) is ours, and Hungary folds in 8 seconds if we keep it. Poland (40 troops) and Slovakia (41) border it, so the priority is reinforcing 24 and building its garrison. Gold is 40, which covers the 35g War Camp upgrade on 24. Austria and Switzerland sit at or near cap, so I'm sending half of each toward 24.

<orders>
BUILD 24
SEND 50% FROM 109 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 24
</orders>
201:3596%
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 25
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 26 TO 24
Reply
Czechia (25) costs 22 troops to take and is adjacent to our capital (24), which holds 48. Sending 75% of 24 gives about 36 attackers, enough to win with some left over. That drains the capital, so I'm reinforcing it from the interior provinces 28 and 26.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 25
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 26 TO 24
</orders>
211:40107%
BUILD 25 A
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 101
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 21
RALLY 24 TO 15
Reply
The best immediate move is taking Tunisia, which costs 21 and is within reach of Italy's 32 troops. Czechia's workshops are the best use of the 45 gold, since they add +13 gold/min. Albania's capital can reinforce besieged Greece, which is the staging point for Egypt. The Hungary war camp can aim at Poland for later.

<orders>
BUILD 25 A
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 101
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 21
RALLY 24 TO 15
</orders>
221:45107%
SEND 75% FROM 27 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 26,129 TO 27
Reply
I'll try to retake Greece from Turkey now. Serbia and the capital together can cover its cost of 20. Croatia and Bosnia then reinforce Serbia, which borders the Turkish front.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 27 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 26,129 TO 27
</orders>
231:5096%
BUILD 21
SEND 75% FROM 109,128 TO 11
RALLY 24 TO 15
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 21
SEND 75% FROM 109,128 TO 11
RALLY 24 TO 15
</orders>
241:5596%
BUILD 11
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 21
SEND 75% FROM 27 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 26 TO 24
Reply
Building ITALY first is affordable (35 of 37 gold) and adds about 13 gold/min. Greece is the cheapest target in range (cost 18). Sending half the capital's garrison and 75% of Serbia's should take it with margin. I'm also moving half of the interior Croatia garrison to Hungary to build up for a later push on Poland.

<orders>
BUILD 11
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 21
SEND 75% FROM 27 TO 21
SEND 50% FROM 26 TO 24
</orders>
252:0096%
SEND 50% FROM 24 TO 27
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 9
Reply
Serbia (27) costs 10 to take and Hungary is over its cap at 40/27, so I'm sending half of Hungary's garrison there. France's capital (9) costs 8, and a 75% push from Switzerland (13 troops) beats it. Greece is lost to the siege, so I'm not spending troops there. Gold is too low to build.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 24 TO 27
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 9
</orders>
262:0586%
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
Reply
Italy is the cheapest target in reach. Croatia and Albania together can send about 34 troops against its cost of 16. I'm holding back Czechia and Austria, since Germany's cost of 36 is too high for them to take alone right now.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
</orders>
272:1096%
BUILD 11 A
SEND 100% FROM 11 TO 9
Reply
Italy has 14 troops against France's capital at 7 (cost 7). Sending all of it should take the capital. Developing Italy to workshops first adds gold without spending troops.

<orders>
BUILD 11 A
SEND 100% FROM 11 TO 9
</orders>
282:1596%
SEND 75% FROM 25 TO 10
SEND 100% FROM 109 TO 10
RALLY 24 TO 27
RALLY 26 TO 27
Reply
Germany (10) is the cheapest real target: cost 37, and I can send about 47 from Czechia and Austria. Hungary and Croatia are war camps, so I'm redirecting both at Serbia (27, cost 53), which is closer to reachable than Bulgaria (cost 66). The capital stays untouched.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 25 TO 10
SEND 100% FROM 109 TO 10
RALLY 24 TO 27
RALLY 26 TO 27
</orders>
292:2096%
SEND 100% FROM 129,26 TO 27
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 27
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 129,26 TO 27
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 27
</orders>
302:2575%
SEND 100% FROM 26,109 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 11
BUILD 25
Reply
Serbia (15 troops) can't hold against Ukraine's 65 arriving now, so I'm not spending troops there. The best target is Italy: its cost is 12, and I can reach it from three of my provinces. Sending all of Croatia and Austria plus half of Switzerland gives about 19 troops against 12. I'm keeping the capital at full strength, since Greece (50) is next to it. Czechia's Factory Lines upgrade is the strongest economic buy, and it costs 56 of my 111 gold.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 26,109 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 11
BUILD 25
</orders>
312:3064%
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 9
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
BUILD 129
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 9
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
BUILD 129
</orders>
322:3575%
SEND 100% FROM 25 TO 10
SEND 75% FROM 109,128 TO 10
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 25 TO 10
SEND 75% FROM 109,128 TO 10
</orders>
332:4075%
BUILD 11
Reply
Italy is the only affordable development. Its +13 gold/min will fund later attacks. No attack is winnable this turn. Serbia (cost 53) needs more than the 36-troop Croatia-Czechia-Bosnia strike, and sending the capital's garrison would leave Albania exposed to Greece. The war camp at Croatia is already rallying toward Serbia, so I'll let troops accumulate.

<orders>
BUILD 11
</orders>
342:4575%
SEND 100% FROM 26,109,25 TO 24
RALLY 26 TO 24
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 26,109,25 TO 24
RALLY 26 TO 24
</orders>
352:5075%
SEND 50% FROM 24,25 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 129,128 TO 11
BUILD 24
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 24,25 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 129,128 TO 11
BUILD 24
</orders>
362:5575%
SEND 50% FROM 26,109 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 15
SEND 100% FROM 25 TO 15
SEND 25% FROM 28 TO 128refused: ALBANIA#28 has no route to SWITZERLAND#128
Reply
The Italy province (11) is cheap at 4 troops, so I'm sending half of each of 26 and 109 to take it. Poland (15) costs 9, so I'm committing 24 and 25 together to clear it. Capital 28 is over its cap, so I'm moving a quarter of its troops to Switzerland (128) as reinforcement.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 26,109 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 15
SEND 100% FROM 25 TO 15
SEND 25% FROM 28 TO 128
</orders>
373:0075%
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 129
BUILD 11
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 129
BUILD 11
</orders>
383:0586%
BUILD 11 A
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 9
SEND 100% FROM 129 TO 27
RALLY 26 TO 27
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 11 A
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 9
SEND 100% FROM 129 TO 27
RALLY 26 TO 27
</orders>
393:1096%
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 27
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 27
BUILD 24
Reply
Serbia (27) is the nearest target I can take. Its cost is 15, and I can field 27 troops against it: 50% of the capital's 33 plus 75% of Croatia's 15. The capital keeps 17. Hungary is at 0 troops, so I'll develop it into a war camp to build up its garrison.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 27
SEND 75% FROM 26 TO 27
BUILD 24
</orders>
403:1586%
SEND 50% FROM 27,109 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 25 TO 15
BUILD 27 A
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 27,109 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 25 TO 15
BUILD 27 A
</orders>
413:2096%
BUILD 24
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 11,128 TO 10
Reply
The Poland capital (15) is the cheapest capture: 5 defenders against a cost of 6. Hungary can send 75% of its garrison (about 10 troops) to take it. Germany's capital (10) needs 13 troops, so I'm combining 75% from Italy and Switzerland for about 28, which wins comfortably. I'm also building the Hungary war camp for 25 gold, which leaves 36 in reserve.

<orders>
BUILD 24
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 11,128 TO 10
</orders>
423:25107%
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 109 TO 11
BUILD 109
Reply
Turkey's 32 troops will overrun Serbia (12 troops) in about a second, so I'm not trying to hold it. Italy (11) is the closest soft target: it has 13 troops and borders my capital and Austria. Sending half of each should take it while keeping both home garrisons above their minimums. I'm also developing Austria to a garrison keep to strengthen that front.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 109 TO 11
BUILD 109
</orders>
433:3086%
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 27
BUILD 11 A
RALLY 26 TO 27
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 27
BUILD 11 A
RALLY 26 TO 27
</orders>
443:3575%
SEND 50% FROM 11 TO 9
SEND 50% FROM 26,129 TO 27
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 11 TO 9
SEND 50% FROM 26,129 TO 27
</orders>
453:4096%
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 21
BUILD 27
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 28 TO 21
BUILD 27
</orders>
463:4596%
SEND 75% FROM 25 TO 15
BUILD 11 A
Reply
The best immediate gain is Poland (15). Czechia's 37 troops can take it at 75%, which should win with about 10 left. Italy's factory-lines upgrade is the strongest economy build, and 61 gold covers its 56 cost. Greece (5 troops, under siege by Egypt and Algeria) is too weak to save, and France and Hungary cost more than I can send right now.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 25 TO 15
BUILD 11 A
</orders>
473:5086%
SEND 75% FROM 11,128 TO 9
Reply
Italy and Switzerland can together take France's capital (cost 11) with a 75% send, so I'm committing both there. Other targets are too costly for my current garrisons.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 11,128 TO 9
</orders>
483:5596%
SEND 100% FROM 26 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 25
Reply
Hungary (24) is the best target: its cost is 27 and my two adjacent provinces can send about 49 troops. Taking it also removes an attacker from Czechia's border. I'm also sending reinforcements from my capital to Czechia, which is under siege at 25 troops against Ukraine's 25. I'm skipping the France development because Argentina's 46 troops arrive there next and will take it.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 26 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 25
</orders>
494:0086%
SEND 50% FROM 25 TO 15
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 24
BUILD 27
Reply
Poland (15) costs 5 troops to take and is only held by 6, so I'm sending half of Czechia's garrison there. Hungary (24) costs 7 against 9 defenders, so I'm sending half of Serbia's. I'm also developing Serbia to Garrison Keep, since it sits full at its cap of 25 and the upgrade raises both cap and defence.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 25 TO 15
SEND 50% FROM 27 TO 24
BUILD 27
</orders>
504:0586%
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 101
BUILD 28 Arefused: not enough gold for ALBANIA#28 (105, you have 51)
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 101
BUILD 28 A
</orders>
514:1086%
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 101
BUILD 128
Reply
Tunisia is the cheapest target: it costs 14 and Italy can send 24 of its 32 troops across the sea. Switzerland can be developed with the 58 gold on hand, which adds garrison and defence to a border province.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 101
BUILD 128
</orders>
524:1586%
SEND 75% FROM 109,26 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 25 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 101
Reply
I'm attacking Hungary (24) and Tunisia (101), the two targets I can take with a clear troop margin.

- **Hungary (24):** Ukraine holds it with 41 troops, and the cost right now is 32. I'm sending 75% from Austria (109) and Croatia (26), plus 50% from Czechia (25), for about 50 troops in total.
- **Tunisia (101):** Morocco holds it with 7 troops, and the cost is 7. I'm sending 75% from Italy (11), which is 12 troops.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 109,26 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 25 TO 24
SEND 75% FROM 11 TO 101
</orders>
534:2086%
SEND 50% FROM 27,109 TO 24
Reply
Hungary's capital (24) is the cheapest target: it costs 7 troops and I can send 24 from Serbia and Austria. Germany and Greece are too strong to attack, and I'm holding back gold for now.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 27,109 TO 24
</orders>
544:2596%
SEND 100% FROM 24 TO 23
SEND 75% FROM 27 TO 23
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
BUILD 24
Reply
Romania (23) is the best target: cost 35, and Hungary plus most of Serbia can reach it for about 48 troops. Italy needs reinforcing on the France and Germany border, so I'm moving half the capital's garrison there. Hungary is over its cap, so I'm developing it to a war camp.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 24 TO 23
SEND 75% FROM 27 TO 23
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
BUILD 24
</orders>
554:3075%
SEND 25% FROM 11 TO 9
SEND 50% FROM 23,26,109 TO 24
BUILD 23
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 11 TO 9
SEND 50% FROM 23,26,109 TO 24
BUILD 23
</orders>
564:3586%
SEND 100% FROM 128 TO 9
SEND 75% FROM 129 TO 128
BUILD 26 A
Reply
Italy is under siege by Morocco with 11 troops, and I can't reinforce it in time. Switzerland (27 troops) can take France (cost 24) now, so I'm attacking with it. Bosnia is at full garrison and wasting output, so I'm moving most of its troops into Switzerland to back the push. Croatia gets the Raider Lodges upgrade with the gold I have.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 128 TO 9
SEND 75% FROM 129 TO 128
BUILD 26 A
</orders>
574:4075%
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 109refused: SWITZERLAND#128 has no route to AUSTRIA#109
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 109
</orders>

Italy (11) has 16 defenders against our cost of 17, so the 26 troops from the capital should take it with about 10 left. Switzerland's surplus moves to Austria (109) to stage for Hungary and Czechia.
584:4564%waited
Reply
 I can order right now is likely to win, so I'm waiting.

- **Hungary (24, cost 32):** The 4-troop column arriving in 0s is too small. Croatia (16) or Austria (16) alone can't reach 32, and sending one would just lose the fight.
- **France (9, cost 35):** Switzerland is full at 34 and can send at most 33 at 100%, one short of the cost.
- **Moldova (133, cost 37):** Romania has 0 troops, so it can't send anything.
- **Capital and staging:** Albania (35/47) borders Greece and Serbia, both strong, so I'm not pulling its troops. I also don't know that Croatia and Albania are adjacent, so I'm not staging through them.

Romania is empty and exposed, but it refills over time and nothing I have can reinforce it safely yet. I'm holding gold at 17 until I know the cost of a build.

<orders></orders>
594:5054%
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 9
RALLY 26 TO 24
Reply
Holding 5 provinces against 11 rivals, I'll take the one cheap target and aim Croatia's war camp at Hungary.

- **France (9):** Cost is 21 and Canada holds 20 there. Sending 75% of Switzerland's 34 troops (about 25) clears it with a small margin. Switzerland keeps about 9, which is weak against Germany and Italy, but it still holds the fortress.
- **Hungary (24):** Cost is 36 and Indonesia holds 35, so I can't take it yet. Rallying Croatia's war camp to it builds up troops over time.
- **Capital (28):** Greece costs 148 and Serbia 319, so I'm keeping the capital's 43 troops at home.
- **Build:** I'm holding the 18 gold until I know what a develop costs.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 9
RALLY 26 TO 24
</orders>
604:5554%
SEND 75% FROM 28,109,26 TO 11
Reply
Italy (11) is the best target in reach: its cost is 60 and 75% from three of my provinces should total about 72 troops. The capital keeps 11 troops after sending, but it refills, and the attack opens a route toward Morocco's territory.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 28,109,26 TO 11
</orders>
615:0054%
SEND 25% FROM 128 TO 9
SEND 100% FROM 26 TO 28
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 128 TO 9
SEND 100% FROM 26 TO 28
</orders>
625:0554%
SEND 100% FROM 128,11 TO 9
BUILD 28 A
Reply
The attack on France (9) is the best available target. Combining Switzerland (22) and Italy (6) gives about 27 troops against its 20 defenders, above the 21 cost. Gold goes to the capital's Ramparts, since Indonesia's 4,968 troops make holding 28 the priority.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 128,11 TO 9
BUILD 28 A
</orders>
635:1054%
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 129 TO 128refused: BOSNIA#129 has no route to SWITZERLAND#128
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 129 TO 128
</orders>
645:1554%
SEND 50% FROM 109 TO 25
BUILD 28refused: not enough gold for ALBANIA#28 (175, you have 18)
Reply
Czechia (25) is the cheapest target: it costs 7 troops to take, and a 50% send from Austria (109) gives 16. Province 9 (France) costs 30, and my two neighbours can only muster about 27 after keeping one troop each, so I'll wait. I'm also developing the capital for economy.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 109 TO 25
BUILD 28
</orders>
655:2054%
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 28refused: BOSNIA#129 has no route to ALBANIA#28
Reply
Hungary (24) is the cheapest capture: 14 troops to take, and 75% of Austria's garrison (109) sends 17. Italy (11) is under siege by Morocco with 18 troops against 32, so I'm reinforcing it from Switzerland (128). Bosnia (129) is at its cap, so I'm moving half its surplus to the capital.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 24
SEND 50% FROM 128 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 28
</orders>
665:2554%
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 109refused: BOSNIA#129 has no route to AUSTRIA#109
SEND 25% FROM 28 TO 128refused: ALBANIA#28 has no route to SWITZERLAND#128
Reply
Hungary (9 troops) will fall to the five Indonesian armies arriving within 5 seconds, so I won't spend troops or gold there. Bosnia is full at 34/34 and has a route to Austria, which borders Croatia and Germany, so I'm moving half its garrison there. I'm also sending a quarter of the capital's surplus to Switzerland, which sits next to Italy and Germany. The capital stays above 40 troops.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 129 TO 109
SEND 25% FROM 28 TO 128
</orders>
675:3043%
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 25
BUILD 28 Arefused: not enough gold for ALBANIA#28 (175, you have 85)
Reply
Austria (109) has 19 troops and borders Czechia (25), which Indonesia holds with 10 troops against a cost of 11. Sending 75% from 109 (about 14 troops) should take it. Our capital is over its cap at 61/59, so I'm spending some of its gold on a build.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 25
BUILD 28 A
</orders>
685:3543%
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 10
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 128refused: ALBANIA#28 has no route to SWITZERLAND#128
Reply
Germany (10) is the best target. Indonesia holds it with 13 troops, and the cost is 14. Sending 75% of Switzerland (128) gives about 21 troops. I'm also moving half of the capital's surplus into Switzerland to cover the gap it leaves. Austria (109) is under a 49-troop siege and can't be saved this turn, and I can't afford a build yet.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 10
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 128
</orders>
695:4032%
BUILD 28refused: not enough gold for ALBANIA#28 (175, you have 93)
Reply
The capital holds 60 troops, Bosnia is full at 34, and Croatia's cost is 95. Combined sends from 28 and 129 give 94, which falls short, so attacking now would fail. I'll develop the capital for defence and hold troops until we can take a target.

<orders>
BUILD 28
</orders>
705:4532%
SEND 100% FROM 28 TO 26
Reply
Albania is badly outnumbered, so the aim is to hold as much ground as possible. Indonesia's 51-troop attack on Bosnia arrives immediately and I can't stop it. The best available move is to take Croatia (cost 46) with the capital's full 59 troops.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 28 TO 26
</orders>
715:5032%
BUILD 28refused: not enough gold for ALBANIA#28 (175, you have 104)
Reply
We're badly outnumbered: 57 troops against Indonesia's 6,860, and every neighbour's cost is far above what we can send. Attacking now would just lose troops, so I'm building up the capital's development to strengthen its defence and holding the rest.

<orders>
BUILD 28
</orders>
725:5532%
BUILD 128 A
Reply
The gold covers one development, and Switzerland (128) is the province under the most pressure, bordering France, Italy and Germany. Ramparts raise its cap and defence, so I'm developing it. Every other option is a losing attack: the cheapest target costs 156 troops and I have 78. I'll hold the rest of the garrison in place.

<orders>
BUILD 128 A
</orders>
736:0032%waited
Reply
Every neighbouring target costs far more than I can field: the cheapest, Serbia, needs 198 troops and my largest garrison is 41. Bosnia is under siege with 4 troops, but it doesn't border Switzerland or the capital, so I can't reinforce it. Attacking now would only throw away troops, so I'll hold and let the garrisons refill.

<orders></orders>
746:0521%waited
Reply
Every neighbour costs far more than I can field: the cheapest, Serbia (27), needs 198 troops and I have 88 at most. Attacking would just throw away garrison. Both my provinces are at or near cap, so I'll hold and let garrisons refill while gold builds up.

<orders></orders>
756:1021%
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 28refused: SWITZERLAND#128 has no route to ALBANIA#28
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 128 TO 28
</orders>
766:1511%
BUILD 128refused: not enough gold for SWITZERLAND#128 (175, you have 17)
Reply
Switzerland is my only province, and I have no route to the capital, so I can't retake it within the 18-second window. Attacking the neighbours (cost 215 to 236 against my 48 troops) would only throw troops away. I'll keep the garrison intact and try to strengthen Switzerland with the 17 gold.

<orders>
BUILD 128
</orders>
776:2011%waited
Reply
Our only province is Switzerland with 48 troops, and every neighbour is held by Indonesia at a cost of 195 to 215 troops. Attacking now would just lose the army, and we can't reach the Albanian capital through the bordering provinces. We also have only 18 gold, so no build is affordable. Waiting is the only sensible order this decision.

<orders></orders>
786:2511%
SEND 100% FROM 128 TO 28refused: SWITZERLAND#128 has no route to ALBANIA#28
BUILD 128 Arefused: not enough gold for SWITZERLAND#128 (175, you have 19)
Reply
Our only province is Switzerland (48 troops). Albania is not adjacent to it, and every bordering enemy costs 180 or more, so we can't take any neighbour. The only move that could stop the capital from folding is to send everything at Albania (28) now. The route is unconfirmed, so this may fail. I'm also developing Switzerland with the 19 gold to raise its defence.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 128 TO 28
BUILD 128 A
</orders>
796:3011%waited
Reply
Albania's capital is held by Indonesia with 215 troops, and my only province, Switzerland, has 48 with no route to it. Every bordering target costs 198 to 215 troops to take, which I can't reach. Attacking now would throw away the garrison, and I have only 20 gold, so I can't build. Waiting keeps the 48 troops in place.

<orders></orders>