NATIONS ROYALE BENCHMARK · EASY

Claude Sonnet 5.5 as VNM, Easy war 1

Won at 4:19 of game time, holding 103 provinces, 74% of the world, after 52 decisions and 3 refused orders. The game's reference player won at 4:08 on the same war. All of Claude Sonnet 5.5's wars.

RESULTWon
GAME TIME4:19
HELD103 · 74%
DECISIONS52
REFUSED3 of 206
MODEL TIME5.1 min
COST$0.959 (API-equivalent)
TOKENS IN / OUT200,759 / 30,429
REQUESTS52
Share of the world at each decisionThe share of the world's provinces it held each time the war paused. Dashed lines mark the 70% seal and what the game's reference player held at the end of the same war.
0%20%40%60%80%051015Reference 75%Seal 70%Game minutes

The game's players on this war

PlayerResultHeldGame time
Claude Sonnet 5.5Won74%4:19
Reference playerWon75%4:08
Reference on the model's clockWon73%5:34
Sharp personaWon78%4:26
Median personaWon74%5:38
Tourist personaTimed out7%15:00

Every decision

What it held when the war paused, the orders it gave, and what the game refused and why. The war file carries an arcade-session/1 envelope: the war key and this order stream replay this exact war at Nations Royale commit e426bd2.

DecisionClockHeldOrders
10:0011%
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 93
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 104
BUILD 41
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 93
SEND 25% FROM 41 TO 104
BUILD 41
</orders>
20:0532%
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 67
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
BUILD 104
BUILD 93
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 67
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 82
BUILD 104
BUILD 93
</orders>
30:1054%
BUILD 67
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 67
</orders>
40:1554%
BUILD 82refused: not enough gold for MALAYSIA#82 (35, you have 24)
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 82
</orders>
50:2054%
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 37
SEND 75% FROM 104,93,67 TO 37
Reply
I'm attacking Bangladesh's capital (37), the weakest neighbour. It costs 85 troops to take, and the troops I'm sending add up to about 154. The capital (41) sends only 50% so it keeps a garrison against China and Thailand. I can't afford a build yet (24 gold against a cost of 35).

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 37
SEND 75% FROM 104,93,67 TO 37
</orders>
60:2554%
SEND 100% FROM 67 TO 37
BUILD 82refused: not enough gold for MALAYSIA#82 (35, you have 31)
Reply
Bangladesh's capital holds only 6 troops, and its cost is 8. Myanmar (67) has 23 troops, so I'm sending all of them against it. Capturing a capital takes the whole nation. I'm also spending the 31 gold on developing Malaysia (82), my second-largest garrison.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 67 TO 37
BUILD 82
</orders>
70:3064%
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 38
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 38
SEND 100% FROM 37 TO 35
SEND 50% FROM 67 TO 35
BUILD 37
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 38
SEND 75% FROM 93 TO 38
SEND 100% FROM 37 TO 35
SEND 50% FROM 67 TO 35
BUILD 37
</orders>
80:3575%
SEND 100% FROM 37,67 TO 35
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 38
Reply
I'm holding China's capital (38), which folds to me in 19s, and attacking India's capital (35) from 37 and 67. Together they send about 38 troops against the 33 needed. Half of the capital's garrison (41) goes to reinforce 38 against the Philippine siege of 26.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 37,67 TO 35
SEND 50% FROM 41 TO 38
</orders>
90:4086%
SEND 25% FROM 35 TO 130
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 90
BUILD 35refused: not enough gold for INDIA#35 (35, you have 29)
Reply
Orders this turn:
- Hold CHINA's capital (38) so it folds in 14s.
- Take SRI LANKA with 25% of INDIA's garrison.
- Take KYRGYZSTAN with 50% of CHINA's garrison.
- Build on INDIA with the 29 gold. I don't know the build cost, so it may not go through.

<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 35 TO 130
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 90
BUILD 35
</orders>
100:45107%
BUILD 38
SEND 50% FROM 104,35 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 90
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 38
SEND 50% FROM 104,35 TO 38
SEND 50% FROM 93 TO 90
</orders>
110:50107%
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 50
SEND 75% FROM 90 TO 99
SEND 75% FROM 37 TO 38
Reply
Holding China's capital (38) is the priority, since it folds in 4s. It has 91 troops against the 18 marching in from Nepal, so it stays safe even after a send. I'm taking the cheap neutral provinces and reinforcing 38 from the interior.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 38 TO 50
SEND 75% FROM 90 TO 99
SEND 75% FROM 37 TO 38
</orders>
120:551410%
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 40
SEND 75% FROM 90 TO 70
SEND 75% FROM 134,103,37 TO 99
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 38 TO 40
SEND 75% FROM 90 TO 70
SEND 75% FROM 134,103,37 TO 99
</orders>
131:001612%
SEND 75% FROM 99 TO 65
SEND 75% FROM 40,38 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 130,103,134 TO 70
BUILD 40
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 99 TO 65
SEND 75% FROM 40,38 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 130,103,134 TO 70
BUILD 40
</orders>
141:051712%
SEND 50% FROM 40 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 67,93,104 TO 42
SEND 75% FROM 90,38 TO 48
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 40 TO 102
SEND 75% FROM 67,93,104 TO 42
SEND 75% FROM 90,38 TO 48
</orders>
151:101813%
SEND 50% FROM 41,67,82,93,104 TO 42
SEND 25% FROM 90 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 70 TO 74
BUILD 70
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 41,67,82,93,104 TO 42
SEND 25% FROM 90 TO 48
SEND 50% FROM 70 TO 74
BUILD 70
</orders>
161:152115%
SEND 100% FROM 35,99,65,38 TO 36
SEND 75% FROM 48,74 TO 110
BUILD 42
Reply
I'm sending the border armies at Pakistan's capital (province 36) and Turkey's weak province 110 (Azerbaijan). I'm also spending the 41 gold on a muster at Thailand.

- **Pakistan capital (36):** it holds 72 troops and costs 87. Provinces 35, 99, 65 and 38 together send about 165 at 100%, which is enough to take it and eliminate Pakistan.
- **Azerbaijan (110):** it holds 24 troops and costs 24. Provinces 48 and 74 send about 41 at 75%, which is enough.
- **Build:** Thailand (42) holds 134 troops facing Indonesia across the sea, so a muster there should help it stream troops to the front.

<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 35,99,65,38 TO 36
SEND 75% FROM 48,74 TO 110
BUILD 42
</orders>
171:202216%
SEND 100% FROM 35,38,65,99 TO 36
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 35,38,65,99 TO 36
</orders>
181:252317%
SEND 25% FROM 36 TO 87
BUILD 110
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 36 TO 87
BUILD 110
</orders>
191:302417%
SEND 75% FROM 38,40 TO 138
SEND 50% FROM 65 TO 87
BUILD 50
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 38,40 TO 138
SEND 50% FROM 65 TO 87
BUILD 50
</orders>
201:352417%
SEND 50% FROM 40 TO 138
SEND 50% FROM 36,65,74 TO 51
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 78
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 123
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 40 TO 138
SEND 50% FROM 36,65,74 TO 51
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 78
SEND 50% FROM 87 TO 123
</orders>
211:402820%
SEND 100% FROM 138,102 TO 39
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 100% FROM 78 TO 58
SEND 100% FROM 70,104,36,65 TO 123
BUILD 138
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 138,102 TO 39
SEND 75% FROM 87 TO 75
SEND 100% FROM 78 TO 58
SEND 100% FROM 70,104,36,65 TO 123
BUILD 138
</orders>
221:453022%
SEND 75% FROM 123 TO 34
SEND 75% FROM 40,138 TO 39
BUILD 123
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 123 TO 34
SEND 75% FROM 40,138 TO 39
BUILD 123
</orders>
231:503223%
SEND 75% FROM 58 TO 71
SEND 75% FROM 34 TO 119
SEND 100% FROM 123 TO 34
BUILD 34
BUILD 48
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 58 TO 71
SEND 75% FROM 34 TO 119
SEND 100% FROM 123 TO 34
BUILD 34
BUILD 48
</orders>
241:553324%
SEND 50% FROM 34 TO 119
SEND 100% FROM 38,138,82 TO 43
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 34 TO 119
SEND 100% FROM 38,138,82 TO 43
</orders>
252:003424%
SEND 100% FROM 138,82,38 TO 43
SEND 75% FROM 58,75 TO 47
SEND 75% FROM 119 TO 96
BUILD 119
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 138,82,38 TO 43
SEND 75% FROM 58,75 TO 47
SEND 75% FROM 119 TO 96
BUILD 119
</orders>
262:053626%
SEND 50% FROM 58,75 TO 47
SEND 75% FROM 71 TO 92
BUILD 40
Reply
I'm taking Kenya's capital with the troops already besieging it, and Uganda with a spare force from South Sudan. Gold goes into Factory Lines at S. Korea.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 58,75 TO 47
SEND 75% FROM 71 TO 92
BUILD 40
</orders>
272:103827%
SEND 75% FROM 51,96,110,119 TO 22
SEND 75% FROM 47 TO 63
SEND 75% FROM 38,39,48,50,40 TO 17
BUILD 47
Reply
I'm sending three attacks this turn and one build.

- **Turkey:** its capital (22) costs 54, so I'm sending 75% from Iran, Syria, Azerbaijan and Jordan.
- **Tanzania:** I'm taking the neutral province (cost 18) with 75% of Kenya's garrison.
- **Russia:** its capital (17) costs 174, so I'm sending 75% from China, Japan, Kazakhstan, Mongolia and S. Korea, about 337 troops. This should take the nation's capital and all 3 of its provinces.
- **Build:** a war camp on Kenya for 35g.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 51,96,110,119 TO 22
SEND 75% FROM 47 TO 63
SEND 75% FROM 38,39,48,50,40 TO 17
BUILD 47
</orders>
282:154029%
SEND 25% FROM 22 TO 106
SEND 50% FROM 63 TO 111
SEND 50% FROM 38,48,50,110,39 TO 17
BUILD 22
BUILD 58
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 22 TO 106
SEND 50% FROM 63 TO 111
SEND 50% FROM 38,48,50,110,39 TO 17
BUILD 22
BUILD 58
</orders>
292:204130%
SEND 50% FROM 48,50,38,39 TO 17
SEND 25% FROM 22 TO 106
SEND 75% FROM 119 TO 77
BUILD 71
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 48,50,38,39 TO 17
SEND 25% FROM 22 TO 106
SEND 75% FROM 119 TO 77
BUILD 71
</orders>
302:254331%
BUILD 138
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 50% FROM 22 TO 106
SEND 75% FROM 111,63 TO 64
Reply
<orders>
BUILD 138
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 116
SEND 50% FROM 22 TO 106
SEND 75% FROM 111,63 TO 64
</orders>
312:304532%
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 85
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 117
SEND 75% FROM 22,110 TO 121
SEND 75% FROM 58 TO 52
SEND 75% FROM 64 TO 66
BUILD 77
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 85
SEND 25% FROM 17 TO 117
SEND 75% FROM 22,110 TO 121
SEND 75% FROM 58 TO 52
SEND 75% FROM 64 TO 66
BUILD 77
</orders>
322:354935%
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 72
SEND 100% FROM 66 TO 62
SEND 100% FROM 64 TO 73
SEND 75% FROM 121,51,77 TO 17
BUILD 63
BUILD 78
Reply
Here are this turn's orders:

- **Cent. Africa:** half of S. Sudan (89 troops) goes after Cent. Africa, which costs 23.
- **Namibia and Madagascar:** Zambia and Mozambique commit everything against two cheap neutrals, Namibia (cost 15) and Madagascar (cost 17).
- **Russia staging:** big interior garrisons at Georgia, Iran and Iraq move to Russia, where Sweden is about to strike. This also stages them for a push on Poland or Ukraine.
- **Builds:** I've spent the 74 gold on Muster Grounds at Tanzania and Stone Walls at Yemen.

<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 71 TO 72
SEND 100% FROM 66 TO 62
SEND 100% FROM 64 TO 73
SEND 75% FROM 121,51,77 TO 17
BUILD 63
BUILD 78
</orders>
332:405439%
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 21
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 49
SEND 75% FROM 58,78 TO 115
BUILD 34
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 21
SEND 75% FROM 63 TO 49
SEND 75% FROM 58,78 TO 115
BUILD 34
</orders>
342:455741%
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 16
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 19
SEND 75% FROM 66 TO 55
SEND 50% FROM 49 TO 84
BUILD 17
BUILD 106
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 16
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 19
SEND 75% FROM 66 TO 55
SEND 50% FROM 49 TO 84
BUILD 17
BUILD 106
</orders>
352:505942%
SEND 25% FROM 66 TO 83
SEND 25% FROM 66 TO 69
SEND 100% FROM 62,64 TO 31
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 19
BUILD 66
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 66 TO 83
SEND 25% FROM 66 TO 69
SEND 100% FROM 62,64 TO 31
SEND 75% FROM 17 TO 19
BUILD 66
</orders>
362:556144%
SEND 75% FROM 69,83 TO 31
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 84 TO 91
SEND 100% FROM 85,17 TO 16
BUILD 66
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 69,83 TO 31
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 84 TO 91
SEND 100% FROM 85,17 TO 16
BUILD 66
</orders>
373:006547%
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 75% FROM 16 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 84,72 TO 79
BUILD 77
BUILD 16
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 25% FROM 16 TO 133
SEND 75% FROM 16 TO 15
SEND 75% FROM 84,72 TO 79
BUILD 77
BUILD 16
</orders>
383:056748%
SEND 50% FROM 16,117,116 TO 15
SEND 100% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 34,119,52 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 27
BUILD 31
BUILD 49
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 16,117,116 TO 15
SEND 100% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 75% FROM 34,119,52 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 27
BUILD 31
BUILD 49
</orders>
393:106849%
SEND 25% FROM 15 TO 10
SEND 50% FROM 34,119 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 21,106 TO 27
BUILD 123
Reply
<orders>
SEND 25% FROM 15 TO 10
SEND 50% FROM 34,119 TO 29
SEND 75% FROM 21,106 TO 27
BUILD 123
</orders>
403:157050%
SEND 50% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 122
BUILD 34 B
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 21 TO 28
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 122
BUILD 34 B
</orders>
413:207151%
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 23
SEND 100% FROM 16 TO 124
BUILD 52
BUILD 79
Reply
I'm sending Bulgaria's garrison at Romania's capital and Ukraine's at Slovakia. The other two orders spend gold on development: Sudan and Cameroon are the picks for border-province upgrades.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 23
SEND 100% FROM 16 TO 124
BUILD 52
BUILD 79
</orders>
423:257353%
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 23
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 26
SEND 100% FROM 27 TO 129
SEND 50% FROM 52 TO 54
BUILD 122
BUILD 28
BUILD 29
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 106 TO 23
SEND 50% FROM 28 TO 26
SEND 100% FROM 27 TO 129
SEND 50% FROM 52 TO 54
BUILD 122
BUILD 28
BUILD 29
</orders>
433:307655%
SEND 75% FROM 26,27 TO 129
SEND 75% FROM 29,52,21 TO 53
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 75% FROM 23,124,16 TO 24
SEND 100% FROM 54,79 TO 57
BUILD 17
BUILD 23
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 26,27 TO 129
SEND 75% FROM 29,52,21 TO 53
SEND 50% FROM 17 TO 68
SEND 75% FROM 23,124,16 TO 24
SEND 100% FROM 54,79 TO 57
BUILD 17
BUILD 23
</orders>
443:357957%
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 25
SEND 75% FROM 53 TO 101
BUILD 138 B
Reply
I'm striking Czechia's capital and Tunisia this turn, and spending gold on an economy upgrade.

- **Czechia:** 75% of Hungary's 187 troops goes to the capital at province 25. That is about 140 against a cost of 75, and taking it eliminates Czechia.
- **Tunisia:** 75% of Libya's 175 troops goes to province 101. That is about 131 against a cost of 57.
- **Niger:** I'm leaving it alone because our siege force of 60 is already against its 10 defenders.
- **Germany and Italy:** I'm skipping both. Poland's 57 troops can't beat Germany's 59, and Albania would need nearly everything it has for Italy's 138.
- **Build:** Taiwan (138) goes to the Treasury doctrine (B) for +90 gold/min, at 150g of our 232.

<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 24 TO 25
SEND 75% FROM 53 TO 101
BUILD 138 B
</orders>
453:408360%
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 18
SEND 75% FROM 15,25 TO 10
SEND 75% FROM 79,57,91 TO 30
SEND 100% FROM 53,101 TO 33
SEND 75% FROM 24,26 TO 109
BUILD 31
BUILD 16
BUILD 52
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 18
SEND 75% FROM 15,25 TO 10
SEND 75% FROM 79,57,91 TO 30
SEND 100% FROM 53,101 TO 33
SEND 75% FROM 24,26 TO 109
BUILD 31
BUILD 16
BUILD 52
</orders>
463:458763%
SEND 75% FROM 53 TO 33
SEND 100% FROM 28,109,10,26 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 14
SEND 75% FROM 18 TO 125
BUILD 19
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 53 TO 33
SEND 100% FROM 28,109,10,26 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 19 TO 14
SEND 75% FROM 18 TO 125
BUILD 19
</orders>
473:508964%
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 14
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 53 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 33 TO 56
SEND 50% FROM 30 TO 113
SEND 50% FROM 54 TO 88
SEND 75% FROM 31 TO 32
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 10 TO 14
SEND 75% FROM 109 TO 11
SEND 75% FROM 53 TO 11
SEND 50% FROM 33 TO 56
SEND 50% FROM 30 TO 113
SEND 50% FROM 54 TO 88
SEND 75% FROM 31 TO 32
</orders>
483:559468%
SEND 75% FROM 88 TO 127
SEND 100% FROM 56 TO 86
SEND 50% FROM 11 TO 9
BUILD 34
BUILD 138
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 88 TO 127
SEND 100% FROM 56 TO 86
SEND 50% FROM 11 TO 9
BUILD 34
BUILD 138
</orders>
494:009770%
SEND 75% FROM 10,11 TO 128
SEND 100% FROM 56 TO 97
BUILD 66 B
Reply
<orders>
SEND 75% FROM 10,11 TO 128
SEND 100% FROM 56 TO 97
BUILD 66 B
</orders>
504:059870%
SEND 100% FROM 33 TO 32
SEND 25% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 59
SEND 100% FROM 88,127 TO 46
BUILD 66
Reply
<orders>
SEND 100% FROM 33 TO 32
SEND 25% FROM 56 TO 97
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 59
SEND 100% FROM 88,127 TO 46
BUILD 66
</orders>
514:1010173%
SEND 50% FROM 32 TO 59
SEND 75% FROM 86 TO 89
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 89
BUILD 56
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 32 TO 59
SEND 75% FROM 86 TO 89
SEND 50% FROM 56 TO 89
BUILD 56
</orders>
524:1510374%
SEND 50% FROM 86 TO 118
SEND 75% FROM 89 TO 126
Reply
<orders>
SEND 50% FROM 86 TO 118
SEND 75% FROM 89 TO 126
</orders>