NONOGRAMS BENCHMARK · 5 BY 5

Qwen3.8 27B on 5 by 5 puzzle 1

Solved: 25 of 25 cells right, 10 of 10 rows and columns matching their clues. It said it was 100% sure. All of Qwen3.8 27B's puzzles.

RESULTSolved
CELLS RIGHT25 / 25
LINES RIGHT10 / 10
SAID100% sure
MODEL TIME6.0 min
COSTlocal, no list price
TOKENS IN / OUT331 / 2,709
REQUESTS1

filled, right empty, right filled, should be empty empty, should be filled ? left unknown 3 1 a clue the answer breaks

The end of its reply

ed two runs: one of length 1, one of length 2, in order (left to right).

Total filled cells: 3.

Possible structures:

Since col1 is filled, and clue starts with `1`, the first run is length 1 → so col2 must be empty (else run would be longer).

So col2 = `.`

Now we have: `# . . ? ?`

Remaining cells: col4 and col5.

We need a run of length 2. The only two adjacent cells left are col4–col5.

So to get a run of length 2, we must have col4 = # and col5 = #.

Then the runs are:
- Run1: col1 (length 1)
- Run2: col4–5 (length 2)

And they are separated by col2 and col3 (both empty), so valid.

Thus, row5: `# . . # #`

Any other possibility? What if the run of length 2 is col3–col4? But col3 is empty (fixed), so no.

What if run of length 1 is at col4 and run of length 2 is... no, col3 is empty, so col4–5 is the only possible adjacent pair.

So row5 is uniquely: `# . . # #`

---

### Step 6: Summarize known rows

From above:

- Row1: `# . . ? ?` with either col4 or col5 filled (not both), and the other empty.
- Row2: `# # . . .`
- Row3: `# # . . .`
- Row4: `# . . . .`
- Row5: `# . . # #`

Now let’s tabulate column 2, 4, and 5.

We know:

**Column 2 clue: `2`**

So exactly two filled cells in col2.

From rows:

- Row1: col2 = `.` (we deduced this)
- Row2: col2 = `#`
- Row3: col2 = `#`
- Row4: col2 = `.`
- Row5: col2 = `.`

So col2 filled in rows 2 and 3 → exactly two. ✅ Satisfies clue `2`.

Good.

**Column 4 clue: `1`**

So exactly one filled cell in col4.

Look at col4 across rows:

- Row1: ? (either # or .)
- Row2: .
- Row3: .
- Row4: .
- Row5: #

So row5, col4 = # (from row5 = `# . . # #`)

So col4 already has at least one filled cell (row5).

Clue says exactly one, so **no other row can have col4 filled**.

Therefore, row1, col4 must be `.`

Then, from row1’s two options, we must choose the one where col5 is filled.

So row1: `# . . . #`

Now check col4: only row5 has # → ✅ clue `1` satisfied.

**Column 5 clue: `1 1`**

So two filled cells, non-adjacent.

Look at col5:

- Row1: # (just set)
- Row2: .
- Row3: .
- Row4: .
- Row5: #

So filled in rows 1 and 5.

Are they non-adjacent? Rows 1 and 5: difference is 4 ≥ 2 → yes, separated by at least one empty (rows 2–4 empty).

So runs: row1 (length 1), row5 (length 1) → clue `1 1` ✅

Also, no other filled cells in col5.

Perfect.

Now let’s write the full grid:

Row1: `# . . . #` → `#...#`
Row2: `# # . . .` → `##...`
Row3: `# # . . .` → `##...`
Row4: `# . . . .` → `#....`
Row5: `# . . # #` → `#..##`

Double-check all clues:

**Rows:**
- R1: `#...#` → runs: pos1 (len1), pos5 (len1) → `1 1` ✅
- R2: `##...` → run of 2 at start → `2` ✅
- R3: `##...` → `2` ✅
- R4: `#....` → single # → `1` ✅
- R5: `#..##` → run1: pos1 (len1), run2: pos4–5 (len2) → `1 2` ✅

**Columns:**
- C1: all # → `5` ✅
- C2: rows2,3 # → `2` ✅
- C3: all . → `0` ✅
- C4: only row5 # → `1` ✅
- C5: row1 and row5 # → non-adjacent → `1 1` ✅

All satisfied. Unique solution.

<grid>
#...#
##...
##...
#....
#..##
</grid>
<confidence>100</confidence>

Puzzle 5x5-0 of set v1, 5 by 5.