NONOGRAMS BENCHMARK ยท 20 BY 20

Qwen3.5 9B on 20 by 20 puzzle 1

No readable grid: 0 of 400 cells right, 0 of 40 rows and columns matching their clues. All of Qwen3.5 9B's puzzles.

RESULTNo readable grid
CELLS RIGHT0 / 400
LINES RIGHT0 / 40
SAIDn/a
MODEL TIME6.7 min
COSTlocal, no list price
TOKENS IN / OUT2,372 / 3,000
REQUESTS2

filled, right empty, right filled, should be empty empty, should be filled ? left unknown 3 1 a clue the answer breaks

The end of its reply

= 12$.
   - Run 2 length 8 $\implies$ Rows 13 to 20 ($20-13+1 = 8$). Matches.
   - Conclusion: **Row 12** in Column 10 is empty (`.`). Others filled.

**3. Analyze Row 10 (`2, 7, 2`):**
   - Sum: $2+7+2=11$. Gap size = $20-11 = 9$.
   - We know C9 R10 is `#` and C10 R10 is `.` (from step 2).
   - The pattern must satisfy C9 (`#`) being filled.
   - If the big run of 7 starts at col $x$, it covers $x$ to $x+6$.
   - Since C10 is a gap, the run of 7 cannot cross C10? Or can the gap be part of the separated runs?
   - Let's look at Col 9 again. It is `#`. In Row 10, C9 is filled.
   - If the big run is columns 4-10 (length 7), then C9 is inside it. But we found C10 R10 is a gap (`.`). So the run cannot include C10.
   - Therefore, the run of 7 in Row 10 must end at or before C9? Or start after C10?
   - Wait, if C10 R10 is `.` (gap), then the filled cells around it must be separate runs.
   - Run of 7 cannot contain a gap. So the run of 7 must be entirely to the left or entirely to the right of the gap in Row 10? No, the column logic determines specific cells. The row logic determines the horizontal pattern.
   - If C10 R10 is `.` (empty), then the "gap" in the row sum could be the cell at C10, or another cell.
   - However, Row 10 needs a gap of size $20-11=9$.
   - Let's re-evaluate C10. Col 10 has `11, 8`. Gap at R12. So R12 is empty. R1-R11 and R13-R20 are filled.
   - Back to Row 10. It has a `.` at C10? Let's check if C10 R10 is filled. Yes, C10 has filled cells from R1-11. So R10-C10 is `#`.
   - My previous deduction "Row 12 in Column 10 is empty" was correct. So Row 10 Col 10 is `#`.
   - If R10-C10 is `#`, and Row 10 needs runs `2, 7, 2`.
   - Can the run of 7 include C10? Yes.
   - Can the gap in Row 10 be elsewhere? Sum=11. Length=20. Gap=9.
   - If the gap is at C1, run starts C2-C8 (len 7)? Then C9-C20 filled (12 cells). But clue says `2, 7, 2`.
   - Let's solve intersections carefully later.

**Let's use a programmatic approach simulation in thought:**

*   **Col 9**: `12, 7`. Gap at Row 13.
    *   Grid[0..12][8] = '#', Grid[13][8] = '.', Grid[14..19][8] = '#'. (Indices 0-19).
*   **Col 10**: `11, 8`. Gap at Row 12.
    *   Grid[0..11][9] = '#', Grid[12][9] = '.', Grid[13..19][9] = '#'.
*   **Row 10**: `2, 7, 2`.
    *   Needs runs of length 2, 7, 2. Total 11 filled. Gap=9.
    *   We know Col 9 (index 8) is `#` and Col 10 (index 9) is `#`.
    *   If Col 9 and 10 are both `#`, they must be part of the same run or adjacent runs? Runs must be separated by at least 1 empty. So C9 and C10 cannot be separate runs if both filled. They must belong to one run.
    *   Since max run is 7, and we have two consecutive filled cells (C9, C10), they are likely in the run of 7.
    *   If the run of 7 includes C9 and C10, where does it go?
    *   Possible runs of 7 containing indices 8,9: [2..8], [3..9], ..., [9..15].
    *   If run is [3..9] (indices), then Col 2 (idx 1) to Col 8 (idx 8) are filled. But C9 is idx 8? Wait. Index 8 is Col 9. Index

Puzzle 20x20-0 of set v1, 20 by 20.