Qwen3.5 9B on 15 by 15 puzzle 1
No readable grid: 0 of 225 cells right, 0 of 30 rows and columns matching their clues. All of Qwen3.5 9B's puzzles.
RESULTNo readable grid
CELLS RIGHT0 / 225
LINES RIGHT0 / 30
SAIDn/a
MODEL TIME4.5 min
COSTlocal, no list price
TOKENS IN / OUT2,070 / 3,000
REQUESTS2
2
3
23
3
12
3
4
21
4
614122
5
21
4
1
12
2
31
2
22
1
24
2
15
53
1
41
7
17 5???????????????3 3 4???????????????2 3 3???????????????4 2 1???????????????7 2???????????????7 1???????????????4 1???????????????1 4 3 1???????????????6 1 4???????????????6 3 3???????????????7 1 3???????????????1 4 1 5???????????????3 4???????????????1 3 2???????????????2 1???????????????
3
23
3
12
3
4
21
4
614122
5
21
4
1
12
2
31
2
22
1
24
2
15
53
1
41
7
17 5???????????????3 3 4???????????????2 3 3???????????????4 2 1???????????????7 2???????????????7 1???????????????4 1???????????????1 4 3 1???????????????6 1 4???????????????6 3 3???????????????7 1 3???????????????1 4 1 5???????????????3 4???????????????1 3 2???????????????2 1???????????????
filled, right empty, right filled, should be empty empty, should be filled ? left unknown 3 1 a clue the answer breaks
The end of its reply
= 8.
* **Row 14** (Clue: 1, 3, 2). Total filled = 6. Gaps = 9.
Let's try to fix the position of the empty cells in Col 5 and Col 6.
In **Col 5**, if Row 1 is `.` and Rows 2-15 are `#`:
- Row 1 must accommodate its clues without Col 5 filled. Clue `7, 5`.
- If Row 1 Col 5 is `.`, then the run of 7 and run of 5 must be arranged around it.
- Possible arrangements for `7, 5` with a gap at col 5?
Indices: 1,2,3,4,5(.),6,7,8...
Run 7 could be cols 1-7 (filled 1-7). But col 5 is filled. Contradiction.
Run 7 could be cols 1-4? No, length 7.
If gap is at 5:
Option A: Run 7 at 1-4 (impossible, len 3), Run 7 at 2-8? (cols 2-8). Then col 5 is filled.
Wait, if Col 5 is empty, then neither run can cover column 5.
So the gap must be inside a run? No, gaps separate runs.
If Col 5 is `.` in Row 1, then we have two runs separated by this gap or the gap is one of the required gaps.
Clue `7, 5`. Minimum space = $7 + 1 + 5 = 13$. Max space 15.
Gap at 5 means cells 1-4 (4 cells) and 6-10 (5 cells)? No.
If the gap is at index $k$, then we need $k \ge 7$ for the first run to end before it? Or start after?
If Run 1 ends at $e_1$ and Run 2 starts at $s_2$. Gap is between them.
If Col 5 is empty, it acts as a separator.
Case 1: Run 1 is `1-7`, Run 2 is `9-13`. Gap at 8? No, we need gap at 5.
If gap is at 5: Run 1 must be in 1-4 (len 4) - impossible for len 7.
Or Run 1 is in 1-?, Run 2 in ?, 6-?.
Actually, if Col 5 is empty, it counts as the separator between the two runs OR part of the leading/trailing gap.
If Clue is `7, 5`:
Possible placements with a hole at 5:
- Run 1 (7) + Gap (1) + Run 2 (5) -> Indices $x$ to $x+6$, then $x+7$, then $y$ to $y+4$.
- If hole is at 5:
- Option A: Run 1 ends at 4? Length 7 impossible in 1-4.
- Option B: Run 1 starts after 5? No, index < 5.
- Option C: Run 1 spans across? No, filled cells are contiguous.
- Conclusion: If there is a single empty cell at Col 5, and the clue has two groups, that empty cell MUST be one of the mandatory gaps between the groups OR an extra gap at start/end.
- To fit `7` and `5` with exactly one forced empty cell (from Col 5 constraint) plus necessary gaps:
Min width = $7 + 1 (\text{sep}) + 5 = 13$.
We have 15 cells. Extra space = 2.
If the extra space is placed at the top or bottom, the gap between groups stays at index $(start+6)+1$.
Where can the single "extra" gap go? Top (row 1), Bottom (row 15).
If the gap from Col 5 constraint is at Row $r$, does it conflict with row logic?
Let's look at **Row 1** (`7, 5`) and **Row 15** (`2, 1`).
Hypothesis: The empty cell in Col 5 is at Row 1. Why?
If Row 1 ColPuzzle 15x15-0 of set v1, 15 by 15.